excellent thread, i just found it thru google
i took the liberty of copying the first post onto my blog
and gave the proper props, of course
السلام عليكم
http://abumubarak.wordpress.com/2010/11/19/blame-it-on-the-muslims-naturally
in all due respect akhi
i think we do enough reminders of our Prophet all day long, from the salat and darood, and following the sunnah in our daily lives
a birthday celebration is nothing more than imitation of the kufar and their ways
we dont see the Prophet nor any of his companions...