Assalamu aleikum
I have started a discussion with Mr. Suhaib Webb about some things I don´t agree in his web-site. It´s my personal opinion. I don´t agree with anyone who spread sufi ideas among us.
After some emails that I used to justify my opinion and after requesting him to stop spreading sufi ideas and texts in his web-site I realise something very wierd to me. Muslims in USA don´t have a good future.
I am not here to judge anyone, but in fact I have my doubts if Islam acording with Ahl As-Sunnah wal-Jama‘ah is the principal path difused among them.
Iman Suhaib have got realy upset about my opinions.
He said:
"First question:
"How much Qur'an have you memorized?"
Second Question:
"Outside of the internet, what major scholars have you studied Fiqh with?"
Don't run away, answer and let's continue this discussion."
I could not understand the reason for these questions.
I was not talking about Qur´an or other kind of subject. I was just expressing my point of view, because someone who are studing at Alzhar University to become a "muslim leader" cannot agree with sufi ideas. Nowadays sufism is connected with many wrong ideas and inovations, I think it is not good to a muslims getting envolved with them.
I am not saying the Suhaib Web is a sufi. But I have got surprised with his reaction. He was I little arrogant but I am not so sure, talking with someone by emails is not the same.
I said:
"I can point sufi ideas that are totaly away from the Ahl As-Sunnah wal-Jama‘ah"
He said:
"..., why don't you share with me your educational qualification that allows you to make such a call.?"
If you are not a scholar you have no right to express your opinion.
It was my mistake to try warning him about it, and now I know it.
After read this post everything was made clear to me:
abulhaarith.wordpress.com/2008/08/20/the-position-of-ahlus-sunnah-towards-the-soofees/
And after reading this post the thing have gotten more clear yet:
abulhaarith.wordpress.com/2009/01/21/o-ahlus-sunnah-why-do-you-waste-your-time-debating/
I hope he will not become like hamza yusuf who is for me a sufi and a dangerous one. Take a look at one book recomended by him:
sheikhhamza.com/v1_reco.asp?mode=&reco_id=144
I would like to hope from suhaib webb, but Allah (SubhanaWaTaallah) knows better.
Salam
I have started a discussion with Mr. Suhaib Webb about some things I don´t agree in his web-site. It´s my personal opinion. I don´t agree with anyone who spread sufi ideas among us.
After some emails that I used to justify my opinion and after requesting him to stop spreading sufi ideas and texts in his web-site I realise something very wierd to me. Muslims in USA don´t have a good future.
I am not here to judge anyone, but in fact I have my doubts if Islam acording with Ahl As-Sunnah wal-Jama‘ah is the principal path difused among them.
Iman Suhaib have got realy upset about my opinions.
He said:
"First question:
"How much Qur'an have you memorized?"
Second Question:
"Outside of the internet, what major scholars have you studied Fiqh with?"
Don't run away, answer and let's continue this discussion."
I could not understand the reason for these questions.
I was not talking about Qur´an or other kind of subject. I was just expressing my point of view, because someone who are studing at Alzhar University to become a "muslim leader" cannot agree with sufi ideas. Nowadays sufism is connected with many wrong ideas and inovations, I think it is not good to a muslims getting envolved with them.
I am not saying the Suhaib Web is a sufi. But I have got surprised with his reaction. He was I little arrogant but I am not so sure, talking with someone by emails is not the same.
I said:
"I can point sufi ideas that are totaly away from the Ahl As-Sunnah wal-Jama‘ah"
He said:
"..., why don't you share with me your educational qualification that allows you to make such a call.?"
If you are not a scholar you have no right to express your opinion.
It was my mistake to try warning him about it, and now I know it.
After read this post everything was made clear to me:
abulhaarith.wordpress.com/2008/08/20/the-position-of-ahlus-sunnah-towards-the-soofees/
And after reading this post the thing have gotten more clear yet:
abulhaarith.wordpress.com/2009/01/21/o-ahlus-sunnah-why-do-you-waste-your-time-debating/
I hope he will not become like hamza yusuf who is for me a sufi and a dangerous one. Take a look at one book recomended by him:
sheikhhamza.com/v1_reco.asp?mode=&reco_id=144
I would like to hope from suhaib webb, but Allah (SubhanaWaTaallah) knows better.
Salam