Search results

  1. H

    Need help!

    Nobody is denying that the Quran wasn't written. But that wasn't and has never been considered the primary form of preservation of the Quran. The Quran is preserved orally, from heart to heart, as Allah says بل هو آيت بينت في صدور الذين أوتوا العلم, especially given the fact that our Ummah is...
  2. H

    Need help!

    What's your point pal? I saw see you mentioning: You are half right here. Quran has been preserved through the hearts of men as well as written down on paper, leather, stone etc as soon as they were revealed. Do you deny those narrations or not? Did the Prophet not appointed some of his...
  3. H

    Need help!

    Since you have failed to answer the four simple questions, let's try this route: ok ok Really? ok ok Can you even read and understand Arabic?
  4. H

    Need help!

    I'm sorry but you've virtually failed on all accounts regarding answering the questions I posed to you. Instead, you resorted to giving a long lecture - again. Your multiple spelling mistakes makes me think you are not even worthy of being taken seriously. You are unable to give simple...
  5. H

    Need help!

    Look if you can't answer, then that would simply be indicative of your lack of knowledge, lack of transparency, and lack of willing to engage in an open discussion (not an argument). I'll repeat the questions for you, which I'm sure everyone here would like to know your answers to. 1. Have you...
  6. H

    Need help!

    mezeren, I want for brief answers, not a lecture. Try again - I'll simplify things even further: 1. Have you read the books of Tafsir to see how they reconcile between what you claim is a contradiction between the verse and the Hadith? Yes or no. If yes, which ones? 2. Is everything in the...
  7. H

    Need help!

    Wassalam Four simple questions: 1. Have you read the books of Tafsir to see how they reconcile between what you claim is a contradiction between the verse and the Hadith? 2. Are you aware that the issue of the dead hearing is a matter of difference within the Ahl 'l-Sunnah? Do you even...
  8. H

    Marriage without a wali for the girl || Hanafi fiqh

    Wassalam It's already been shed. Three divorces occur in Hanafi law. No, according to the Hanafi jurists. And most other jurists for that matter.
  9. H

    Marriage without a wali for the girl || Hanafi fiqh

    Wassalam Are you sure about that?
  10. H

    The Methodology of the Salaf Concerning Ijtihad and Taqlid

    Here is the full lecture, I advise everyone to listen to it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fisz2HRhLYc And please don't ask me about why he said what he said on some matters of Aqeedah later on in the lecture, because that would be off-topic and you can discuss it on another thread. Yes I...
  11. H

    The Methodology of the Salaf Concerning Ijtihad and Taqlid

    Wassalam I haven't studied the Shafi`i position, or what you are referring to, in depth to be able to speak about it. I apologise. You'll have to find someone else for clarification, preferably a trained Shafi`i scholar or student.
  12. H

    Posts not directly related to ijithad/taqleed thread topic.

    Haneef means turning away from Shirk to Allah alone. Shi`ah in the Quran means 'group'. These are the answers to your really tough questions. But know you'll be wondering 'what is my Daleel'. A vicious cycle.
  13. H

    Posts not directly related to ijithad/taqleed thread topic.

    I think your place is in the circus, not TTI. Thank you for making us all laugh so hard we're getting the cramps. You're refuting us for a meaning we provided for the sword being Hanafi, yet you don't know the meaning yourself!
  14. H

    The Methodology of the Salaf Concerning Ijtihad and Taqlid

    He should take the advice of a trustworthy scholar, or even better, leave it to the scholar if possible.
  15. H

    The Methodology of the Salaf Concerning Ijtihad and Taqlid

    This is off-topic, but since you are the only scholar of Islam to have ever lived: 1. The Prophet never commanded for this activity. You'll never find any such Hadith where he told anybody to do this. 2. Do you join ankles to the next person in Sujood and Jalsah as well? 3. In Sunan Abi...
  16. H

    Posts not directly related to ijithad/taqleed thread topic.

    Sword being Hanafi means either: a) attributed to a person called Ahnaf bin Qays, a Muslim who lived in the prophetic era but never had the chance to meet the Prophet; it is said that he was the first to designed a sword in the manner he did, and it was this design that Prophet's sword was...
  17. H

    Posts not directly related to ijithad/taqleed thread topic.

    The poor chap thinks we're using this Hadith to prove that the Hanafi Madhhab is right! Not only did we ever say that, but he's the one who ended up implying that 'the sword of the Prophet was Imam Abu Hanifah'! Man doesn't even know what Hanafi in the Hadith means, yet is prepared to...
  18. H

    Posts not directly related to ijithad/taqleed thread topic.

    The only answer I got was this: I answered: Are you seriously telling us that "The sword of the Prophet was Nu`man bin Thabit"? (You're beginning to sound like a hardcore Hanafi now) Even I don't say that. Nobody here has said that. Nobody has ever said that. Until you came along... Can you...
  19. H

    Posts not directly related to ijithad/taqleed thread topic.

    Hammy is having some problems in understanding the question. Let's put it this way to Hammy: A non-Muslim man comes to you and asked this question about the explanation of what it means about the sword being Hanafi. What would you say?
Top