Here is the flash (thanx to Sis Renee for sharing this link)
This is the book that my husband and I have compiled together.
Sister what you are quoting there is a lot of doubt on its authenticity as there is no difference between prayer of man and woman.Prophet said pray as you see me praying which is general for both men and women.Here is the fatwa from islam q&a http://www.islam-qa.com/en/pda/ref/islamqa/1106
well i dont know about the hand but what am trying to say that women should bring their feet together and when they say Allahu akhbar their arms should be close to their body.men must do it with wide open.Brother i am not saying that everything that sister said is unauthentic but what i am concerned is about the post men and women difference in salah.In it click the link difference in salah.It redirects to a page where i read that men have to keep hands below navel whereas that hadith has been classified weak by sheikh albani.Doctor Zakir Naik also said that no scholar says that there is any difference in prayer for men and women but that page shows many.
You check this book thoroughly as well because the prophet said that if any person directs something to me which is not reported by me then his abode is hell fire.I understand your devotion towards the islam but at the same time you have to be careful that what you present should be authentic.If any of my words hurt you then i am sorry because i dont want to hurt a pious and devoted muslimah like you.
did u check ur own link well?i guess u didnt read till the end of ur own linkSister what you are quoting there is a lot of doubt on its authenticity as there is no difference between prayer of man and woman.Prophet said pray as you see me praying which is general for both men and women.Here is the fatwa from islam q&a http://www.islam-qa.com/en/pda/ref/islamqa/1106
You check this book thoroughly as well because the prophet said that if any person directs something to me which is not reported by me then his abode is hell fire.I understand your devotion towards the islam but at the same time you have to be careful that what you present should be authentic.If any of my words hurt you then i am sorry because i dont want to hurt a pious and devoted muslimah like you.
Well sister it says only difference is that women should keep body parts close and make stomach touch thighs in sujud.But in the difference in salah link it shows many differences and gives reference of many weak hadith like keeping hands below navel which is hadith of abu dawud and is weak.I am just telling you to be aware of such sites which promote weak hadith.Rest of the material that i checked was absolutely fine and jazakallah very beneficial.Your book i didt read yet but i did not make any comment i just advised you to check that it contains only authentic hadith.I am sorry to make you angry.did u check ur own link well?i guess u didnt read till the end of ur own link
let me tell u what is written in ur link
The author of al-Mughni (2/328) said: "As for the rest of the free woman¡¯s body, it must be covered during prayer. If any part becomes uncovered, it renders her prayer invalid, except if only a little bit is uncovered. Maalik, al-Oozaa¡¯i and al-Shaafi¡¯i said the same. The woman should keep her limbs close to her body during rukoo¡¯ and sujood, and not spread them out, because this is more modest and covering. (Al-Mughni 2/258). Al-Nawawi said: "Al-Shaafi¡¯i said, in al-Mukhtasar: there is no difference between men and women in prayer, except that women should keep the parts of their bodies close to one another, and they should make their stomachs touch their thighs during sujood. This is more covering and preferable, in rukoo¡¯ and the rest of the prayer too."
well i dont know about the man's prayer and even if there is error i will never know coz am a sister and i only concentrate on sisters....the book insyaAllah is fine coz i took from many resources and compiled them together.u dindt make me angry but i was a bit strict.lolWell sister it says only difference is that women should keep body parts close and make stomach touch thighs in sujud.But in the difference in salah link it shows many differences and gives reference of many weak hadith like keeping hands below navel which is hadith of abu dawud and is weak.I am just telling you to be aware of such sites which promote weak hadith.Rest of the material that i checked was absolutely fine and jazakallah very beneficial.Your book i didt read yet but i did not make any comment i just advised you to check that it contains only authentic hadith.I am sorry to make you angry.
Sister i went through the book and interestingly the point about hands which you were saying you dont know is the very second point in the book.Though the book is meant for women (considering the picture part) but this is the way every muslim(male or female)prays as there is no difference between male and female praying.Lastly i thought that your reply may be more strict than the previous ones so i was little bit reluctant in opening this thread.well i dont know about the man's prayer and even if there is error i will never know coz am a sister and i only concentrate on sisters....the book insyaAllah is fine coz i took from many resources and compiled them together.u dindt make me angry but i was a bit strict.lol
well i dont know about the hand but what am trying to say that women should bring their feet together and when they say Allahu akhbar their arms should be close to their body.men must do it with wide open.
Dear sister in ISLAM,
For your kind information our local IMAM also says there is not a single authentic Hadith which says position of body parts in salah for men and women are different. Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) says to both male and female, ''Pray in ways you see me to pray''.
What you mentioned here is applicable only when women are praying in places where man can see them. Suppose you are praying in a market place, street or garden for some reason. In that case you arm and feet should be close to the body. This ruling was applied in EID prayer for the woman. Remember Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) also asked woman to come for EID prayer for praying even you are in your monthly cycle. So ruling of our prophet (PBUH) must be applied only where He applied it. We cannot generalize this.