im really confused

afrarzk

afrarzk

احبك ىارب
Assalamualaikum wr wb


hoping everyone are doing well..........

What is the ruling of responding to the recorded azaan in TV,radio,etcc???.....is it a wrong if v reply to the recoded azaan if we are in a situation where we cant hear the call for prayer(eventhough the mosque is near by)



i guess scholars even has different opinion about this matter...........i dont want to do something out of sunnah .......jst want to knw itz right or wrong.....

it would be helpuful if someone can give me an answer which is logical and from sunnah of our prophet(saw).

jazzakallahu khairan!![/B]
 
A

abjad

AlHamd Li'Laah
afrarzk said:
Assalamualaikum wr wb


hoping everyone are doing well..........

What is the ruling of responding to the recorded azaan in TV,radio,etcc???.....is it a wrong if v reply to the recoded azaan if we are in a situation where we cant hear the call for prayer(eventhough the mosque is near by)



i guess scholars even has different opinion about this matter...........i dont want to do something out of sunnah .......jst want to knw itz right or wrong.....

it would be helpuful if someone can give me an answer which is logical and from sunnah of our prophet(saw).

jazzakallahu khairan!![/b]
Click to expand...

Asalaam aleykum

from my personal point of view I will respond as is suppose 2be;
see especially for hot countries while A-Conditioners etc,almost indoors it is good thing (as reminder)from these sources.
 
afrarzk

afrarzk

احبك ىارب
abjad said:
Asalaam aleykum

from my personal point of view I will respond as is suppose 2be;
see especially for hot countries while A-Conditioners etc,almost indoors it is good thing (as reminder)from these sources.
Click to expand...


waalaikum musalam..

ya true....... but in ma fiqh classes they taught us that itz not right to respod to the recorded azaan ......

and the reason my teacher quoted was " would u follow a jamah which is shown on the TV ....obiviously no right bcoz itz not live.......so she said same way the azaan should be live to respond to it......

it sounds logical........bt wen i searched i found some scholars opined that itz ok to respond if it is in exact time of the azaan........

now from all these im confused whethr to reply or not(i knw itz nt a big issue) still i hear this recorded one evryday in ma office dunno whethr i shuld answer it or not....

so, what am i supposed to do????
 
A

abjad

AlHamd Li'Laah
wa aleykum salaam,

then ask them is it haraam?


Now let us turn the subject to Music lovers.

just hearing being played you might have notice how ?
so it is something within self-and to you have these feelings of Adhan as great words

Allah is the Greatest....I don't see any reason why not to return; by heart.

for your information- United Arab emirates all their adhan are Pre recorded one Adhan to all Masjids;so what is the ruling of 'fiq'h'
 
Itqan Ullah

Itqan Ullah

Time is Running!!
abjad said:
:salam2:

thank you for the site,
how can we reach them if needed?
Click to expand...

Waliekumasslam warahmatullahi wabrakatu,
Use the "send a question" button on left side of page of Islamqa.com, regarding alifta, i didn't notice if it has one. (and it doesn't appear on my phone atleast so can't check at the moment)
 
Aziboy

Aziboy

Banned
Salam Alaykum,

No, you cannot answer the recorded adhaan.

But if anyone would like to learn how to give a call for prayers, he or she can repeat it only for learning purpose.

Also, if you find any of the recorded adhaan soothing i.e. the beautiful voice of the Muazzin, then you can repeat it considering it not to be the Live one of course.
 
afrarzk

afrarzk

احبك ىارب
abjad said:
wa aleykum salaam,

then ask them is it haraam?


Now let us turn the subject to Music lovers.

just hearing being played you might have notice how ?
so it is something within self-and to you have these feelings of Adhan as great words

Allah is the Greatest....I don't see any reason why not to return; by heart.

for your information- United Arab emirates all their adhan are Pre recorded one Adhan to all Masjids;so what is the ruling of 'fiq'h'
Click to expand...


brother, im living in dubai.....n for ur knowledge, in UAE only in abu dhabi and ajman they have made one azaan in all the mosque n moreover v hav dicussed abt this in our fiqh class.............The scholars in sharjah opined that itz not the recorded azaan they are circulating in all the masjid......itz actually a muazin from one mosque do call for prayer and with de help of technology they circulate that to all mosque at the same time......so it is live n nt the recoded one.................they also said that the azaan in the radio n TV n all is recorded long years ago
 
afrarzk

afrarzk

احبك ىارب
Itqan Ullah said:
Asslamaliekum warahmatullahi wabrakatu,
Plz check this out:-
http://islamqa.com/en/ref/148871

Inshallah this should answer your question.

When searching rulings you can refer to http://islamqa.com or www.alifta.net .
Click to expand...


waalaikum musalam wr wb .........

jazzakallahu khairan brother....

one of my favourite trusted site is islamqa..............n in dat i found an q&a which says it is permissible......n datz what it confused me whethr to follow my teacher or the site

check out that q&a

http://islamqa.com/en/ref/87667/responding to adhaan
 
afrarzk

afrarzk

احبك ىارب
Azimax said:
Salam Alaykum,

No, you cannot answer the recorded adhaan.

But if anyone would like to learn how to give a call for prayers, he or she can repeat it only for learning purpose.

Also, if you find any of the recorded adhaan soothing i.e. the beautiful voice of the Muazzin, then you can repeat it considering it not to be the Live one of course.
Click to expand...



waalaikum musalam wr wb.......

jazzakallahu khairan brother.......


Atlast i came to a conclusion that not to repond to the recordeed azaan

thnanks everybody for ur concern........

May Allah help all of us to know the truth about our religion and also to act upon it.....ameen
 
kashif_nazeer

kashif_nazeer

~~~Alhamdulillah~~~
Itqan Ullah said:
Waiyyakum,
Thats strange... 2 contradicting fatwas on islamqa.
Click to expand...

:salam2:

In both fatawa there is one thing common,if it's live not recorded and time for prayer,it is to be responded,if recorded even if prayer time not to be responded.It is not waajib to respond to adhaan it is mashroo3(prescribed) Sunnah.

Quoted
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked about the adhaan on the radio or television: should one respond to it? He replied:

With regard to this adhaan, one of two things must be the case:

(i) It is on the air, i.e., the adhaan is being given at the time of prayer by the muezzin. In this case it should be responded to, because of the general meaning of the command of the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him): “When you hear the muezzin, say what the muezzin says.” But the fuqaha’ (may Allah have mercy on them) said: If he has offered the prayer for which the call is being given, he does not have to respond.

(ii) The adhaan is recorded and is not an adhaan being given at the time; in this case it should not be responded to, because it is not a real adhaan, i.e., the man is not giving it at the time it is commanded to give it; rather it is an audio recording of a previous adhaan.

End quote from Majmoo‘ Fataawa al-Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen, 12/196
Click to expand...

Shaykh Ibn Baaz (may Allaah have mercy on him) was asked: Is it permissible to respond to the adhaan that comes from a radio or TV?

He replied:

If that is at the time of prayer then it is prescribed to respond to it, because the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “When you hear the muezzin then say what he says, then send blessings upon me, for whoever sends one blessing upon me, Allaah will send ten blessings upon him in return, then ask Allaah to grant me al-waseelah, which is a position in Paradise that will be granted to only one slave of Allaah, and I hope that I will be the one, then intercession will be granted to him.” Narrated by Muslim in his Saheeh.

And he (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever says when he hears the call to prayer, ‘Allaahummah Rabba haadhihi’l-da’wat il-taammah wa’l-salaat il-qaa’imah, aati Muhammadan al-waseelata wa’l-fadeelah, wab’athhu maqaaman mahmoodan alladhi wa’adtahu (O Allaah, Lord of this perfect Call and the Prayer to be offered, grant Muhammad the privilege and also the eminence, and resurrect him to the praised position that You have promised), will be granted my intercession on the Day of Resurrection.” Narrated by al-Bukhaari in his Saheeh. Al-Bayhaqi added with a hasan isnaad after the words “that You have promised” “innaka laa tukhlif al-mee’aad (You do not break Your promise).” End quote.

Majmoo’ Fataawa Ibn Baaz (10/363).
Click to expand...
[/COLOR]
 
afrarzk

afrarzk

احبك ىارب
learned a lesseon

kashif_nazeer said:
:salam2:

In both fatawa there is one thing common,if it's live not recorded and time for prayer,it is to be responded,if recorded even if prayer time not to be responded.It is not waajib to respond to adhaan it is mashroo3(prescribed) Sunnah.

Quoted

[/COLOR]
Click to expand...

jazakallahu kairan......
subhanallah....................itz shows how careful we should be in reading each matters.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top