(3) Summoning the spirits of the dead
In recent times talk of summoning the spirits of the dead has become widespread, and many people who are regarded as intelligent and knowledgeable have believed in this lie.
There is more than one way in which the dead are supposedly summoned. Some of that is obviously false, using autosuggestion, various influences and tricks, and some of it is done by using the services of the jinn and devils.
In his book Al-Roohiyyah al-Hadeethah (Modern Spiritualism), Dr. Muhammad Muhammad Husayn uncovers many of the tricks used by these people to distort reality. They only ever do their tricks in a low red light which is virtually dark, so their impersonation of people, direct talk, and moving of objects are all done in intense darkness. The one who is watching cannot distinguish where people are sitting or where voices are coming from, or any of the features of the room, such as its walls, doors and windows.
Dr Muhammad speaks of the alcove which is a side room that is isolated from those present, or a part of the room in which they are sitting that is separated by a thick barrier. This separate place is prepared for the medium at whose hands the supposed materialisation will take place. It is from this place which is screened off in addition to the darkness described above, that the souls of the dead will supposedly materialise and emerge and to which they will return after a short while, and the people present are not allowed to touch the “ghosts.”
Dr. Muhammad thinks that these spiritualists will easily find plenty of methods to do their tricks in such a darkened atmosphere.
Tricking and duping people in this manner is an ancient and well-known method by means of which the devils among mankind lead the slaves of Allah astray, seeking status among the people as well as demanding their money. Ibn Taymiyah (Majmoo’ al-Fataawa, 11/458) spoke of a group in his day which was called Al-Bataa’ihiyyah. They claimed to have knowledge of the unseen and to be able to tell fortunes, and that they could show people the “men of the unseen.” Then he exposed some of their tricks. They used to send women to people’s houses to find out some of the private affairs of their occupants, then they would tell the head of the household of what they had found out, claiming that these were matters of which they had exclusive knowledge.
They promised a man – to whom they were making promises of power – that they would show him the “men of the unseen”, then they set up a long board on which they made people walk. They started walking on the mountain of Al-Mazzah, and that deceived person was watching from a distance and he thought that he saw people walking around a mountain, levitating above the ground. They took a lot of money from him, then he found out what was going on.
They deceived another man whose name was Qafjaq: they put a man in a grave who spoke, and they made him think that the dead were speaking. They brought him to the graveyard of Baab al-Sagheer, to a man who claimed to be Al-Sha’raani from Mount Lebanon (a famous shaykh who had died). They did not bring him close to him, but kept him at a distance, so that he could receive his blessing. They told him that he (the shaykh) was asking for some money. Qafjaq said: “The shaykh knows things and he knows that I do not have all that in my stores.” Qafjaq came closer and pulled the man’s hair, and the goatskin that was covering that person came off.
Dr. Muhammad Muhammad Husayn explained that the medium – i.e., the person whom these spiritualists claim has a natural predisposition to be the means of communication – is usually a great liar and a charlatan.
He stated that many of these mediums have no morals or religious commitment – indeed, the spiritualists do not require any such thing of them. He spoke of things that had happened to him personally which, after he examined them in depth, demonstrated to him that the medium was a great liar.
He described how some of the people present co-operate with those who summon spirits, how they are very careful about whom they allow to attend these gatherings, and how they explain away their failures if there happen to be intelligent and astute people present.
Dr. Muhammad Muhammad Husayn gave a detailed expose of the first way in which the spiritualists claim to summon souls, which is a lie in which they use autosuggestion and scientific trickery.
He refers only briefly to the second way, which is by using the jinn. I think that most the cases in which people claim to have summoned the souls of the dead are of this nature.
In recent times talk of summoning the spirits of the dead has become widespread, and many people who are regarded as intelligent and knowledgeable have believed in this lie.
There is more than one way in which the dead are supposedly summoned. Some of that is obviously false, using autosuggestion, various influences and tricks, and some of it is done by using the services of the jinn and devils.
In his book Al-Roohiyyah al-Hadeethah (Modern Spiritualism), Dr. Muhammad Muhammad Husayn uncovers many of the tricks used by these people to distort reality. They only ever do their tricks in a low red light which is virtually dark, so their impersonation of people, direct talk, and moving of objects are all done in intense darkness. The one who is watching cannot distinguish where people are sitting or where voices are coming from, or any of the features of the room, such as its walls, doors and windows.
Dr Muhammad speaks of the alcove which is a side room that is isolated from those present, or a part of the room in which they are sitting that is separated by a thick barrier. This separate place is prepared for the medium at whose hands the supposed materialisation will take place. It is from this place which is screened off in addition to the darkness described above, that the souls of the dead will supposedly materialise and emerge and to which they will return after a short while, and the people present are not allowed to touch the “ghosts.”
Dr. Muhammad thinks that these spiritualists will easily find plenty of methods to do their tricks in such a darkened atmosphere.
Tricking and duping people in this manner is an ancient and well-known method by means of which the devils among mankind lead the slaves of Allah astray, seeking status among the people as well as demanding their money. Ibn Taymiyah (Majmoo’ al-Fataawa, 11/458) spoke of a group in his day which was called Al-Bataa’ihiyyah. They claimed to have knowledge of the unseen and to be able to tell fortunes, and that they could show people the “men of the unseen.” Then he exposed some of their tricks. They used to send women to people’s houses to find out some of the private affairs of their occupants, then they would tell the head of the household of what they had found out, claiming that these were matters of which they had exclusive knowledge.
They promised a man – to whom they were making promises of power – that they would show him the “men of the unseen”, then they set up a long board on which they made people walk. They started walking on the mountain of Al-Mazzah, and that deceived person was watching from a distance and he thought that he saw people walking around a mountain, levitating above the ground. They took a lot of money from him, then he found out what was going on.
They deceived another man whose name was Qafjaq: they put a man in a grave who spoke, and they made him think that the dead were speaking. They brought him to the graveyard of Baab al-Sagheer, to a man who claimed to be Al-Sha’raani from Mount Lebanon (a famous shaykh who had died). They did not bring him close to him, but kept him at a distance, so that he could receive his blessing. They told him that he (the shaykh) was asking for some money. Qafjaq said: “The shaykh knows things and he knows that I do not have all that in my stores.” Qafjaq came closer and pulled the man’s hair, and the goatskin that was covering that person came off.
Dr. Muhammad Muhammad Husayn explained that the medium – i.e., the person whom these spiritualists claim has a natural predisposition to be the means of communication – is usually a great liar and a charlatan.
He stated that many of these mediums have no morals or religious commitment – indeed, the spiritualists do not require any such thing of them. He spoke of things that had happened to him personally which, after he examined them in depth, demonstrated to him that the medium was a great liar.
He described how some of the people present co-operate with those who summon spirits, how they are very careful about whom they allow to attend these gatherings, and how they explain away their failures if there happen to be intelligent and astute people present.
Dr. Muhammad Muhammad Husayn gave a detailed expose of the first way in which the spiritualists claim to summon souls, which is a lie in which they use autosuggestion and scientific trickery.
He refers only briefly to the second way, which is by using the jinn. I think that most the cases in which people claim to have summoned the souls of the dead are of this nature.