Trinity is solved!

R

Raihan

Junior Member
Christian Trinity:

Father is a God, Son is a God, and Holy Spirit is a God; but there are not three Gods, only one God!

Father is a Person, Son is a Person, and Holy Spirit is a Person; but there are not three Persons, only one Person!

Father is an Almighty, Son is an Almighty, and Holy Spirit is an Almighty; but there are not three Almighty, only one Almighty!

Christians' explanation-1: 1 X 1 X 1 = 1

BUT

Father X Son X Holy Spirit = ???

Moreover, why 1 X 1 X 1 and not 1 + 1 + 1?

Christians' explanation-2: The Trinity is like water: you can see water in 3 different aggregate conditions: liquid, ice, and gas.

BUT

Water, no matter whether it is in liquid or ice or gaseous form, contains the same constituent; i.e. Hydrogen and Oxygen. How about Father, Son, and Holy Spirit? Do they also contain the same constituent? NO! Christian Trinity sounds absurd!

Islamic solution of Christian Trinity:

Father = GOD
Son = Jesus = Messenger of GOD
Holy Spirit = Angel Gabriel
 
Proud2BeHumble

Proud2BeHumble

Seek Truth, Be Happy
Position of Jesus(PBUH) in Islam

:salam2:

No matter how hard they try to prove, truth is clearly evident from their own scriptures. Please refer to the attached pdf file with this message.

Wassalam
 

Attachments

  • Position of Jesus.pdf
    103.6 KB · Views: 19
M

Muhammad_A

Penguin fancier
The water analogy would only hold up if the same volume of water could be in all three states simultaneously. Otherwise it's three seperate volumes of water, one of which is solid, one liquid and one gaseous.

Now... the question is: Which facet of the trinity equates with which state of water? :SMILY335:
 
J

junaid hasan

Banned
jesus didn´t talk about trinity and he also didn´t talk about such theory.

trinity is made by paul and theory also must be made by new christian theologies.
 
J

junaid hasan

Banned
Raihan said:
Christian Trinity:



Christians' explanation-2: The Trinity is like water: you can see water in 3 different aggregate conditions: liquid, ice, and gas.

[/b]
Click to expand...

if water has a form of ice we can see only ice not gas form or liquid form.

but when jesus was there then to whom he had to prayed?

to him self?

if wated is sweet then gas is sweet, liquid is sweet and ice is sweet.

if god is good then why jesus told the people not to call him good?
 
apocalypse77

apocalypse77

Junior Member
Muhammad_A said:
The water analogy would only hold up if the same volume of water could be in all three states simultaneously. Otherwise it's three seperate volumes of water, one of which is solid, one liquid and one gaseous.

Now... the question is: Which facet of the trinity equates with which state of water? :SMILY335:
Click to expand...

white its true water exist in 3 states, they are still WATER. bear in mind that God the Father is God, Son is Flesh and Ghost is Spirit

now christians will claim its not 3 gods but 3 aspects of God in one.

and btw, yes a water CAN be in 3 states but a SINGLE H2O molecule cant be solid, liquid and gas at the same time.
 
apocalypse77

apocalypse77

Junior Member
Christianity is a very complicated religion that certainly did not follow the previous messages of God, delivered by hundreds of prophets before Jesus.

But the Christian apologists have answers to all questions regarding their doctrines. Sometimes those answers just do not make any sense. For example, why did not God reveal before Jesus that he is actually one with three different persons?

Some Christian apologists advocate that God shows us trinity everywhere:

*

Time is divided into past, present, and future and they are all time.
*

Matter is divided into gas, liquid, and solid and they are all matter.
*

Coordinate is divided into X, Y, and Z and they are all coordinates.

Anyone can assemble an argument for duality such as day and night, positive and negative, good and evil, etc. Anyone can assemble an argument from the very many natural facts to strengthen his claim. The Pyramid of Giza was exhausted in numbers to prove that it is a cosmic structure. So where does this leave us? Should we believe in duality, trinity, 15, or other numbers based upon these rationales?

One apologist claims that humanity was not ready for that language of one god with different personalities. The example that he gives to clarify this point is that his son used to call the lid of a can of coke door when he was a child. When his son grew up, he knew that it is the lid that opens the coke!



Similarly, God was one; and when humanity grew up, God revealed that he is still one but with three personalities!

[yt]G_AgcLjXruY[/yt]
 
TheHumbleWun

TheHumbleWun

Banned
Asalaamalikum,

Why make it so complicated by multiplying something by itself?

1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1x1 = 1 why the need to multiply something to itslef when you know the result is going to be 1. If you did this in your math class, you would never finish your exam and people would think you are a fool.

Christianity tries to make things complicated, no wonder so many people are confused.

In Islam it's just 1 book, 1 God, everyone praying in 1 direction. This way is simple and easy to understand - Alhamdulillah

There is a verse even in the Bible, I don't have it with me now, that states the holy spirit is Angel Gabriel, yet it contradicts other verses and leaves people in believing false information!!

The word trinity is found no where in the Bible!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top