Visiting Graves of Dead Family Members?

Sakeena

Junior Member
salam alaikum,

yesterday (sunday) was Mother's Day and my mom and family took us to see some of our elder mothers who are dead. I felt uncomfortable, but I didn't say anything cus I didn't want to be disrespectful, they (my family) prayed to father but I didn't I stayed silent, prayed to Allah not to let me go astray subhanallah. Will I be held to account of what I have done? By visiting?

Oh also is it haram?

thanks

Sakeena :(
 

saffanah

speak good or silent
Sister Sakeena I get this article in a website that insha Allah can answer your confusion about woman visiting the graves.

Visiting graves is recommended in Islaam in order to help the living reflect on the shortness of this life and the closeness of the next. [See Sahih Muslim, vol.2, p.463, #2131]

Women Visiting Graves...

The recommendation to visit graves is general and includes women, just as the earlier prohibition included them without any special mention. Furthermore, women share in the benefits of visiting the graves.

When the Prophet(SAW)found a woman crying in the graveyard, he did not chase her out of the graveyard, but told her not to cry. Anas ibn Maalik related that once the Prophet (SAW) passed by a woman crying beside a grave and said to her, "Fear Allah and be patient." [Sahih Al-Bukhari, vol.2, p.208, #372; Sahih Muslim, vol.2, p.439, #2013]

After mentioning this hadith under the heading Visiting Graves, Ibn Hajar said: The [scholars] disagreed regarding women [visiting graves]. The majority held that they are included in the general permission for visiting graves [if there is no danger of corruption]. The ruling permitting women to visit graves is supported by hadith. The source of evidence in the hadith is the fact that he(SAW) did not censure the woman for sitting beside the grave, and whatever he approves is proof [of it's permissibility]. [Fat-hul-Baaree, vol.4, p.244]

However, frequent visitation of graves by women is not permissable. Hassaan ibn Thaabit narrated that allah's Messenger (SAW) cursed women who frequently visit graves.

Perhaps the reason for not frequenting the graves is the possible negative results of such visits like:

1. The loss of some of their husband's rights due to their frequent absences from the home,

2. The unnecessary public exposure of women,

3. Increased depression leading to wailing and other forbidden expressions of grief.


http://www.muttaqun.com/funerals.html
 

sha587

Shahid abdullah
To visit deadperson's Grave is not a sin but only if you go there for dua.
and deadpersons need our dua and there are many stories about how dead persons wait for good deeds from their living siblings and friends and there is hadith alsoi dont know the exact wordings but it is like this a person left the only good thing in this world is good descendants who pray for his parents.
 

cmelbouzaidi

Junior Member
Dear little sister Sakeena, thanks for bringing this interesting topic up.

Quick question to reverts to Islam: What is your position on attending funerals/burials of loved ones who are Christian, for example? I am the only Muslim in my blood family and feel that if either of my parents or any sibling dies before I do, I would respect the family and tradition and attend the Catholic funeral and burial while reciting Qur'an and duaa to myself. This is my own thinking without investigation, does any revert have experience in this matter? Jazak Allahu Khair.
 
Top