umm hussain
Junior Member
This is another hadeeth utilized by the people of shirk for grave worship and
seeking help from other than Allaah. They use this hadeeth to (falsely) establish
the permissibility of seeking help from the Messenger of Allaah (Sallalahu
Alayhee Was-Sallam).
The Chain
Narrated Abu Nu’maan who heard from Sa’eed bin Zaid who heard from
Amr bin Maalik an-Nukree and it was narrated to him from Abul-Jawzaa
Aws bin Abdullaah who said
The Narration
“The people of Madeenah suffered a very severe drought, so
they complained to A’aishah, so she said, “See the grave of the
Prophet (Sallalahu Alayhee Was-Sallam) and make an opening
in the roof above it, so that there is nothing between it and the
sky.”….”
The Reference
Sunan Daarimee (1/34 no.92), Shaikh al-Albaanee has mentioned (1/43) in his
monumental book at-Tawassul Anwaauhu Wa Ahkaamuhu (pg.126)
seeking help from other than Allaah. They use this hadeeth to (falsely) establish
the permissibility of seeking help from the Messenger of Allaah (Sallalahu
Alayhee Was-Sallam).
The Chain
Narrated Abu Nu’maan who heard from Sa’eed bin Zaid who heard from
Amr bin Maalik an-Nukree and it was narrated to him from Abul-Jawzaa
Aws bin Abdullaah who said
The Narration
“The people of Madeenah suffered a very severe drought, so
they complained to A’aishah, so she said, “See the grave of the
Prophet (Sallalahu Alayhee Was-Sallam) and make an opening
in the roof above it, so that there is nothing between it and the
sky.”….”
The Reference
Sunan Daarimee (1/34 no.92), Shaikh al-Albaanee has mentioned (1/43) in his
monumental book at-Tawassul Anwaauhu Wa Ahkaamuhu (pg.126)
