temporary marriage

blackivy393

Junior Member
did prophet muhammad have temporary marriages? this shia person i know said he did and thats why they believe those are ok
 

palestine

Servant of Allah
oh ok but does anyone know if the prophet muhammad did these ?

i don't believe he did. counting all the wives he ever had and how long they all were married to him, it wasn't temporary marriage. aisha, hafsa,khadijah umm salamah....he was married to all of these women till he had died. and i've never heard of it. i'm guessing this shia person is just saying this to confuse you. when his name is mentioned they don't say "peace be upon him". so i don't see how they would even follow him. they don't practice what he has ordered us too. that's another subject. but the answer is no as far as i know. i'll research more on that.
 

xSharingan01x

TraVeLer
did prophet muhammad have temporary marriages? this shia person i know said he did and thats why they believe those are ok

:salam2:

Not sure why you would find much of the what Shia say credible.
First of all, it is very surprising that they would follow what Prophet SAW did, considering they follow the "sunnah" of their Imams and not of the Prophet SAW. (Read their books of hadeeth).

:wasalam:
 

Abel213

Junior Member
:salam2:
Prophet Muhammad:saw: never had a mutah marriage.

The reason Shia believe that mutah is legal is because they do not accept 90-95% of the Sunnah.
 
Top