Amazing , that in holy Qur'an !!!!

[SWORD OF SUNNA]

Bismallah , Dear brother and sister ,

I wanna ask question ,whenas i know the answer , but to exhort you to search about it .

In quran chapter 16 , verse 8 .
Allah said which mean in english ( And (He has created) horses, mules, and donkeys, for you to ride and use for show; and He has created (other) things of which ye have no knowledge) .

What did scholars educe from this verse ????

 

[dunno]

hello im not a scholar or anything of that sort
but what i think that teach that God created these animals among others to help us in life and that there is many things that God created witch we know nothing about

 

[jaferomar]

:salam2: subhan allah this is amercale for all new things air plane cars ships and so on thank u bother

 

[uzeshan]

:salam2:

I think the answer pretty simple.. There are so many creatures on earth and our side earth and we do not have knowledge about them yet.. If u remembered the story of prophet Suleman PBUH and his invitition to entire creatures of earth.. I hope I am making sence.

 

[SWORD OF SUNNA]

Brothers :dunno,uzeshan
jazakom Allah kiher .

But i mean from context(horses, mules, and donkeys (for ride) in the verse what you educe from ???? And Where is the mircale from this verse !!!


jaferomar : Are you sure ????????? If so what else ????

 

[muslim-girl]

Asc brothers and sisters

Asc brothers and sisters,..

MashaAllah good point, but im sorry to say it in islam its not allow to say " I think, i mean, and so on."
we have to get daleel for it. if u dont know exactly how to translate the ayat, then i know that its haram to translate if u dont have any knowlegde for it. Allah knows best.
dont get me wrong sisters and brothers. i just want the best for me and u, Allah swt will ask us for everthing we say and do..

 

[Boomerang]

Asc brothers and sisters,..

MashaAllah good point, but im sorry to say it in islam its not allow to say " I think, i mean, and so on."
we have to get daleel for it. if u dont know exactly how to translate the ayat, then i know that its haram to translate if u dont have any knowlegde for it. Allah knows best.
dont get me wrong sisters and brothers. i just want the best for me and u, Allah swt will ask us for everthing we say and do..

i think Allah is quiet happy with us thinking....what Allah doesnt want us to do, is spew forth the knowledge of others without thinking about it for ourselves....

so for me, it is allowed to say I think...how is that bad?

i guess you want proof hey muslim girl? its all in Al Quran.......

 

[Steve940]

:salam2:

Surely there isn't a problem with thoughts.


Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 63 :: Hadith 194
Narrated Abu Huraira:

The Prophet said, "Allah has forgiven my followers the evil thoughts that occur to their minds, as long as such thoughts are not put into action or uttered." And Qatada said, "If someone divorces his wife just in his mind, such an unuttered divorce has no effect.:


However, I agree with muslim-girl that we shouldn't speak about things unless we have knowledge. You may state your opinion about a matter, but unless you have knowledge about that affair then your opinion isn't based on any solid proof and it very well may be wrong.

We should take the knowledge of well known and trusted scholars and sheikhs instead of basing our opinions on mere thoughts that could be whispers of the shaytan.

:salam2:

 

[SWORD OF SUNNA]

Steve940,muslim-girl .

Yes ,I agree with you in this case . we should ask scholars because they learn islam well , and have more information .

Anyway , as our brother (jaferomar ) said , i listen to many shieks in tafseer from saudia arabia , said this miracle . and that clear , why??

If the prophet mohamed was a liar -absolutly he's not - , he tried to be de facto at his century .
But the prophet mohamed was massenger of Allah , told as what revealed from God .

Sbhan allah , that's blessing from allah to be muslim .

 

[amirah80]

:salam2:
Good question I was wondering the same thing about that verse! I started towonder if cars played into that our what. If anyone has daleel please post and enlighten us
Salam Sister Amirah

 

[SWORD OF SUNNA]

My sister (amirah80) ,In tafsser (Adwa'a el bayan ) by elshanketee book2,page334, mention it .
also in tafsser Eltaheer Abn a'shoor book14,page111, and tafsser el morakee book14,page57 .

تفسير الشنقيطي و تفسير المراغي وتفسير الطاهر ابن عاشور

You will find in tafsser el shanketee hadeth in muslim -Iman book-,the prophet -peace be upon him- told us in arabic(

(والله لينزلن ابن مريم حكما عادلا فليكسرن الصليب وليقتلن الخنزير وليضعن الجزية ولتتركن القلاص فلا يسعى عليها).. ديث, ومحل الشاهد من هذا الحديث الصحيح ـ قوله (ولتتركن القلاص فلا يسعى عليها) فإنه قسم من النبي ستترك الإبل فلا يسعى عليها, وهذا مُشاهد الآن ألاستغناء عن ركوبها بالمراكب المذكورة, وفي هذا الحديث معجزة عظمى تدل على صحة نبوته rوإن كان معجزاته صلوات الله عليه وسلامه أكثر من أن تحصر"

Which mean : The prophet mohamed -peace be upon him- told us that jesus will return back ,and the common transport which people in usual ride, will be another things -not camels and .so on... .
that what the hadeth means in brief .

Finally, you are right sister :that we must stand for dalel in each think in our religion.

 

[Obase]

Brothers :dunno,uzeshan
jazakom Allah kiher .

But i mean from context(horses, mules, and donkeys (for ride) in the verse what you educe from ???? And Where is the mircale from this verse !!!


jaferomar : Are you sure ????????? If so what else ????

These animals were in great use during the Prophet's time and the only means of transport- so Allah is stating this is a barkah from him. Without these animals how else could they live and travel??

 

[Zainudin Jaffar]

My sister (amirah80) ,In tafsser (Adwa'a el bayan ) by elshanketee 2,page334, mention it .
also in tafsser Eltaheer Abn a'shoor 14,page111, and tafsser el morakee14,page57 .

تفسير الشنقيطي و تفسير المراغي وتفسير الطاهر ابن عاشور

You will find in tafsser el shanketee hadeth in muslim -Iman book-,the prophet -peace be upon him- told us in arabic(

(والله لينزلن ابن مريم حكما عادلا فليكسرن الصليب وليقتلن الخنزير وليضعن الجزية ولتتركن القلاص فلا يسعى عليها).. ديث, ومحل الشاهد من هذا الحديث الصحيح ـ قوله (ولتتركن القلاص فلا يسعى عليها) فإنه قسم من النبي ستترك الإبل فلا يسعى عليها, وهذا مُشاهد الآن ألاستغناء عن ركوبها بالمراكب المذكورة, وفي هذا الحديث معجزة عظمى تدل على صحة نبوته rوإن كان معجزاته صلوات الله عليه وسلامه أكثر من أن تحصر"

Which mean : The prophet mohamed -peace be upon him- told us that jesus will return back , when people in usual ride another things -not camels and .... .
that what the hadeth means in brief .

Finally, you are right sister :that we must stand for dalel in each think in our religion.

Elaborate please! my brain is unusually sluggish today

thanks wassalam