@ Salam2You... darling, you're young right.... I remember being in your shoes, honestly I do, and realizing the world isn't nearly as black and white as it seems. There's not just a case of right and wrong, good guys vs bad guys, but just people. People who can do unimaginable cruelties... thus people who are not equal to others in our sorrow for them.
When you feel sympathy for Gaddafi recall these incidents:
Full Article
(I don't generally like the daily mail because I feel it's sort of tabloidy but...)
Gaddafi Torture Chambers
Go on, view the images, they're graphic, but they're real.
Libyan MASSACRE
Also... their Nurse.. an Ethiopian woman (warning graphic):
[yt]jJDvFhtpFSg[/yt]
These are things that are being uncovered RECENTLY. Imagine 42 YEARS of this.
It's easy to say two wrongs don't make a right, but let's not ever make those 'wrongs' seem equal in any way. One should hate a person to the level of their evil, and love them to the level of their good. And I really would care less how much 'good' the man has done, compared to the level of oppression towards the Muslimeen in the country, and his personal actions, and his wrongs against the Deen - the evil far outweighs ANY good and I can firmly say I hate him.
Now, imagine if these stories were about your brother or sister or close relative in this situation. And in a way they are yours, because surely as you say the Muslims are one Ummah, so they are your brothers and sister, and any Muslim under this situation your heart should go out to as well.
After imagining so, it's a superficial thing to say, "it doesn't matter what he's done..." that trivializes the pain and tears of so many of your brothers and sisters, and is quite hypocritical. Because you know what? If it did happen to YOU, to YOUR family, you wouldn't be standing back saying "it doesn't matter what he's done, let's treat him nicely".
If you do, there's something apathetically wrong with you. Even the Prophet 'alayhi salaatu wa salaam did not treat the man who killed Hamza the same, even after he accepted Islaam.
... Not to mention, yes, scholars are the ones who have the right of takfeer first and foremost. Because of their knowledge and understanding, they can judge the apparent actions of a person and their statements, and issue rulings declaring them as having left the fold of Islaam. Why? Because our Deen is not one where a person can just say or have in their 'heart' that they are Muslims because they've testified to the Shahadah, but it must be apparent through words and deeds. We're not Murji' - these things have a direct correlation to Imaan and being within the fold of Islaam, so scholars and knowledgeable people who are aware of the situation are able to pass this sort of ruling.
And the takfeer of Gaddafi by the scholars is quite well known.
All I hope in the least is that this is some food for thought.
wasalaamu 'alaykum
When you feel sympathy for Gaddafi recall these incidents:
Evidence gathered by Reuters in the provincial town of Khoms shows an organised system of repression with methods including delivering electric shocks to suspects' genitals, keeping them for weeks in baking heat with only a few sips of water a day, and whipping them with an electrical cable while their hands were bound with plastic ties.
The squads allegedly then disposed of their bodies in unmarked graves in a campaign to smash the revolt against his rule.
It was all part of a deliberate strategy, said Nabil Al-Menshaz, an official in the rebel council which took over Khoms after Gaddafi's rule there collapsed last month. "They wanted to frighten the people, so if anyone was thinking of going over to the rebels, they would change their minds," he said.
The brutality of Gaddafi's forces in the capital, Tripoli, in the final, chaotic days before rebels overran the city has been well documented. Dozens of bodies were left lying in the streets, and witnesses described prisoners being massacred before their gaolers fled. Thousands more were killed in battles in cities like Misurata and Zawiyah.
But accounts from Khoms paint a different, and in some ways even more sinister picture. Months before the rebel victory, and out of sight of the outside world, Gaddafi was operating a system of torture - separate from the army and police - that was so well-organised the units has their own command structures and bureaucracy.
Full Article
(I don't generally like the daily mail because I feel it's sort of tabloidy but...)
Gaddafi Torture Chambers
As we went downstairs, there was a door made of heavy iron bars. Inside were four tiny – and empty – cells, about 5ft by 3ft. With their tiled floors, they looked like nothing more than shower rooms. But several prisoners were often stuffed inside, their crimes perhaps nothing more than uttering a word out of place in a nation ruled by fear.
Chillingly, they were still smeared with blood, marking where brutalised prisoners had lain in agony on the ground after the torment of torture. Most terribly of all, in the first cell, there were two bloodstained handprints sliding down a wall.
These bloody handprints from an unknown victim of Gaddafi serve as a potent symbol for his vicious regime. He imposed his 42-year rule on Libyans using the terror of such neighbourhood torture chambers as much as his infamous prisons.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ool-used-brutalise-enemies.html#ixzz1bOFjnUCw
Go on, view the images, they're graphic, but they're real.
The bodies of up to 150 Libyan civilians were found yesterday near Tripoli after allegedly being massacred by pro-Gaddafi forces.
Journalists said they counted as many as 53 executed bodies in a burnt-out farm warehouse near the Khamis military base where the murders are thought to have taken place last Tuesday and Wednesday.
The bodies of two soldiers were found with their hands tied behind their backs. Locals believe they refused to fire on the people being held inside the warehouse, and were then murdered
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ssacred-pro-Gaddafi-forces.html#ixzz1bOG4TWhQ
Libyan MASSACRE
(AP) TRIPOLI, Libya — A bone wrapped with rope and skull fragments scattered over a cactus-covered desert field are grim testament to a 1996 massacre of more than 1,200 prisoners by Muammar Qaddafi's regime.
...The June 26, 1996, killings became a focal point for opposition to Qaddafi who waged fierce crackdowns against any sign of dissent. Most of the inmates were political prisoners, including Islamic clerics and students who had dared to speak against Qaddafi
...He said he was out of the country in 1996 but later spent several years imprisoned himself.
Abu Salim — where for decades Qaddafi had locked up and tortured opponents, or made them disappear — sits empty now after the prisoners were freed as an invading rebel force was sweeping Qaddafi's regime from the capital.
Al-Saadi and other former inmates said they faced torture and inhumane living conditions. Al-Saadi said he was refused medical treatment for a heart condition during his detention.
Read More: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/09/25/501364/main20111392.shtml
Also... their Nurse.. an Ethiopian woman (warning graphic):
[yt]jJDvFhtpFSg[/yt]
These are things that are being uncovered RECENTLY. Imagine 42 YEARS of this.
It's easy to say two wrongs don't make a right, but let's not ever make those 'wrongs' seem equal in any way. One should hate a person to the level of their evil, and love them to the level of their good. And I really would care less how much 'good' the man has done, compared to the level of oppression towards the Muslimeen in the country, and his personal actions, and his wrongs against the Deen - the evil far outweighs ANY good and I can firmly say I hate him.
Now, imagine if these stories were about your brother or sister or close relative in this situation. And in a way they are yours, because surely as you say the Muslims are one Ummah, so they are your brothers and sister, and any Muslim under this situation your heart should go out to as well.
After imagining so, it's a superficial thing to say, "it doesn't matter what he's done..." that trivializes the pain and tears of so many of your brothers and sisters, and is quite hypocritical. Because you know what? If it did happen to YOU, to YOUR family, you wouldn't be standing back saying "it doesn't matter what he's done, let's treat him nicely".
If you do, there's something apathetically wrong with you. Even the Prophet 'alayhi salaatu wa salaam did not treat the man who killed Hamza the same, even after he accepted Islaam.
... Not to mention, yes, scholars are the ones who have the right of takfeer first and foremost. Because of their knowledge and understanding, they can judge the apparent actions of a person and their statements, and issue rulings declaring them as having left the fold of Islaam. Why? Because our Deen is not one where a person can just say or have in their 'heart' that they are Muslims because they've testified to the Shahadah, but it must be apparent through words and deeds. We're not Murji' - these things have a direct correlation to Imaan and being within the fold of Islaam, so scholars and knowledgeable people who are aware of the situation are able to pass this sort of ruling.
And the takfeer of Gaddafi by the scholars is quite well known.
All I hope in the least is that this is some food for thought.
wasalaamu 'alaykum