Help me collecting Bidaa!

Rimatisma

^^^ما لي وللدنيا؟^^^
:salam2:

as the title shows im collecting bidaa insha'Allah,
so please if you know any bidaa, post it here with proof "daleel",
insha'Allah this will help us know every bidaa and avoid them...

jazakom Allah khayr.

:salam2:
 

Steve940

Junior Member
:salam2:

Good idea for a thread, :jazaak:

Is saying Sadaqaallahu Al Azim after reciting or quoting from the Qur'an an innovation, and if it is, how was it introduced?

Praise be to Allaah.

Many people have the habit of ending a recitation from the Qur’aan with the words “Sadaqa Allaahu al-‘Azeem (Almighty Allaah has spoken the truth),” but this has no basis in Islam because the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) did not do it, nor was it the custom of the Sahaabah (may Allaah be pleased with them), and it was unknown among the Taabi’een (the generation after the Sahaabah). This custom arose in later times because some reciters would say these words, on the basis of the aayah: “Say: Allaah has spoken the truth” [Aal ‘Imraan 3:95 – interpretation of the meaning], and people liked this. But this istihsaan (being liked) should be rejected, because if this was really something good, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), the Sahaabah and the Taabi’een – the salaf or first and best generations of the ummah – would not have neglected to do it.

The aayah “Say: Allaah has spoken the truth” (Aal ‘Imraan 3:95 – interpretation of the meaning) does not mean that these words should be said at the end of any reading or recitation. If that were the case, He would have said, “When you finish reading, say ‘Allaah has spoken the truth,’” just as He said (interpretation of the meaning): “So when you want to recite the Qur’aan, seek refuge with Allaah from Shaytaan (Satan), the outcast (the cursed one).” [al-Nahl 16:98]

The aayah which the innovators use to support their practice of saying “Sadaqa Allaah” after reciting Qur’aan was actually revealed in the context of confirming what was said about how all food had been lawful to Bani Isra’eel except what Isra’eel had made unlawful for himself. Allaah said (interpretation of the meaning): “… Say (O Muhammad): ‘Bring here the Tawraat (Torah) and recite it, if you are truthful.’ Then, after that, whosoever shall invent a lie against Allaah, such shall indeed be the zaalimoon (disbelievers). Say (O Muhammad), ‘Allaah has spoken the truth; follow the religion of Ibraaheem (Islamic monotheism, i.e., he used to worship Allaah alone), and he was not of al-mushrikeen (polytheists).” [Aal ‘Imraan 3:93-95]

If this aayah meant that these words should be said after reciting from the Qur’aan, the first one to know and do this would have been the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). Because this is not the case, we know that this is not what was meant.

In conclusion, therefore, saying “Sadaqa Allaahu al-‘Azeem” after reciting Qur’aan is an innovation, and the Muslim should not say it.

But believing that Allaah has spoken the truth is obligatory, and whoever disbelieves or doubts the truth of what Allaah has said is a kaafir who is outside of the pale of Islam. We seek refuge with Allaah from that.

If a person says “Allaah has spoken the truth” on certain occasions, such as when something He has foretold comes to pass, affirming the truth of what He has said, then this is permissible, because something similar has been reported in the Sunnah. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) was giving a speech, and al-Hasan and al-Husayn came along, so he came down from the minbar, picked them up and put them in from of him, then he said: “Indeed Allaah has spoken the truth: ‘Your wealth and your children are only a trial…’ [al-Taghaabun 64:15 – interpretation of the meaning].”

(Izaalat al-sitaar ‘an al-jawaab al-mukhtaar by Ibn ‘Uthaymeen, 79-80).

http://islamqa.com/en/ref/2209/sadaqa


I could not find any evidence but I remember reading somewhere that saying "taqabbal allah" after the prayer is bid'ah but again, no evidence. I searched but could not find anything.


:salam2:
 

Mumin01

Junior Member
are you serious? Whats even the point of this thread? I swear some Muslims love telling people what isnt the deen then what is the deen itself
 

saffanah

speak good or silent
Assalamu'alaikum.

The meaning of Bid'a is : Innovation in Ibadah [worship, i.e. all acts of submission to Allah, as defined in Qur'an and Sunnah]

Some examples of bid'a (innovation):

~Fasting on only Friday (see Bukhari 3:205), on the day of breaking the Ramadan fast (see Bukhari 3:211), or the first day of 'Id ul Fitr and 'Id ul-Adha (see Bukhari 3:211, 213)

~The use of dhikr beads when doing dhikr

The Prophet (peace be upon him) commanded them (the women emigrants) to be regular (in remembering Allah by saying): "Allah is most great"; "Glory be to the King, the Holy"; "there is no god but Allah"; and that they should count them on fingers, for they (the fingers) will be questioned and asked to speak. [Dawood 1496, Narrated Yusayrah, mother of Yasir]

~Placing trust in witchcraft

~Eating donkey meat (see Bukhari 5:511), or animals with fangs (see Bukhari 7:672)

~Drinking out of a gold or silver cup, or eating on a gold or silver plate (see Bukhari 7:337, 722)

~Males wearing silk (see Bukhari 7:718)

~Making du'a while facing a grave (i.e. intentions to seek help in any way from the deceased, whether a prophet or not)

~Celebrating the dunya's(world's matter) holidays

~Celebrating the Prophet saaws' birthday, i.e. Milaad

~Declaring haram (forbidden) something that is not declared haram in the Qur'an or Sunnah
*********************************

When presenting Islam to someone, present Qur'an, not your opinion.

Said Mujahid, "We were in a meeting in the mosque with the companions of Ibn 'Abbas (Tawus, Sa'eed ibn Jubair and 'Ikrimah). When he stood to pray, a man came in and said, 'Is there one who can give a legal verdict?' We said, 'Ask your question.' He said, 'Whenever I urinate, a liquid always follows it.' We asked, 'Is it the type of liquid that gives birth to children?' He said, 'Yes.' We said, 'Then you have to perform ghusl.' The man went away. Ibn 'Abbas hurried to finish his prayer, after which he told 'Ikrimah to bring the man back. He turned to us and said, 'Is your verdict found in the Book of Allah?' We said, 'No.' He asked, 'Is it based on the sayings of the Prophet, upon whom be peace?' We said, 'No.' 'Then from what?' We said, 'From our opinion.' He said, 'That is why the Messenger of Allah said that one learned man is more difficult for Satan than a thousand worshippers.' The man came and faced Ibn 'Abbas, who said to him, 'When that happens, is it owing to any stimulation?' He answered, 'No.' Ibn 'Abbas asked, 'Do you feel any numbness in your body?' He answered, 'No.' Said Ibn 'Abbas, 'That is from the cold. Ablution is sufficient."'

muttaqun.com
 

Waseem203

Young Muslim
are you serious? Whats even the point of this thread? I swear some Muslims love telling people what isnt the deen then what is the deen itself

Hmm, many people could benefit from this thread, espically those who know little about Islam. Not everyone is aware of what Bidah is, and how easily it can be done. I think his intention was to simply inform others on what may have slipped by. :) Salam.
 

Mumin01

Junior Member
Hmm, many people could benefit from this thread, espically those who know little about Islam. Not everyone is aware of what Bidah is, and how easily it can be done. I think his intention was to simply inform others on what may have slipped by. :) Salam.

your right im sorry for those who posted in the thread, i wasnt trying to be rude or disrespectful to anyone, i am just afraid of too many muslims labeling thigns as "bidd'a" everywhere which im sad to see is happening. My apologies to anyone i may have offended
 

adukom2004

New Member
your right im sorry for those who posted in the thread, i wasnt trying to be rude or disrespectful to anyone, i am just afraid of too many muslims labeling thigns as "bidd'a" everywhere which im sad to see is happening. My apologies to anyone i may have offended[/QU

I agree with u Mumin01, i think it is not wise to label
some practise as "bid'a" cos as far as i know our prophet
never accuse someone as "bid'a", he have a very beautifull
way to teach or correct things other than accusing bid'a. Because if we accusing someone as bid'a, it will brought anger and it can broke the unity of muslims and muslim can break apart.
We can see from the history of Islam, our top imam (mazhab) such as Malik, Shafie and etc. Although their opinion is different, they never accuse each other as bid'a. They respect each other opinion. Who is us compare to them.
That just my 2 cents, correct me if i'm wrong.TQ.
 

Rimatisma

^^^ما لي وللدنيا؟^^^
im sorry! my intention is that there's lots of things i hear it's bidaa and i don't know why...
and there's things i don't know if it's bidaa or not...
how could i learn them in other way except this! if you have an idea please tell me i appreciate it :)
also i wanna post other thread about sects in islam because i know nothing about them and what they follow! i wanna learn and have information, many people asked me about sects and i dont know, i wanna know every sect name and what they follow!

if you have an advice it's welcome :)
 

Rimatisma

^^^ما لي وللدنيا؟^^^
brother steve jazak Allah khayr, if u remember more please post them here :)
sister saffanh ur work is appreciated, i think there are things u mentioned are not bidaa but are haram, like man wearing silk, Allah wa rasuluhu a'alam
 

abdellah007

Junior Member
Jazakom allah for Makaing this thread :

Few Bidas which I see in my homeland :

* reciting Quran collectively after Maghreb and before Jummaa Prayers.

* Making Douas loudly after each prayer.

* Rising hands while the Imam is making Doua In jummaa ( only available for Istiska Doua)

these the main bidas I see people doing here.
 

adukom2004

New Member
Jazakom allah for Makaing this thread :

Few Bidas which I see in my homeland :

* reciting Quran collectively after Maghreb and before Jummaa Prayers.

* Making Douas loudly after each prayer.

* Rising hands while the Imam is making Doua In jummaa ( only available for Istiska Doua)

these the main bidas I see people doing here.


:salam2:
What wrong with reciting quran collectively after Maghrib and before Jumma prayer, as far as i know, we can recite quran anytime we want without specific time. The main point is, we must know what are the category of the acts, either it is wajib,sunnah, harus or makruh.
just my 2 cents.
 
Top