Luck haraam?
- Thread starter Kakorot
- Start date
So is it a sin?
Yousef83
Junior Member
no dear sister,i can't say that really.I have no permission to manage u whether its sin or not but up to logic its atheist words.Also usually unbeliever people say these words often.
"Luck" word already enough to keep away.We don't believe luck or anything include luck.Its fate by Allah azze v celle
"Luck" word already enough to keep away.We don't believe luck or anything include luck.Its fate by Allah azze v celle
Assalaam walaikum,
I read that Muslims use fortune as a term and not luck. Luck is a form of shirk ( not my words ). I beleive I read it on this site about a week ago.
Sister...dua is a better use of energy. Secondly, What Allah has willed for us will be. And what He wills for us is good.
I read that Muslims use fortune as a term and not luck. Luck is a form of shirk ( not my words ). I beleive I read it on this site about a week ago.
Sister...dua is a better use of energy. Secondly, What Allah has willed for us will be. And what He wills for us is good.
saifkhan
abd-Allah
Saalma alikum
I didnt understant what you really said. anyways....if that is to say some one, we can just ask them to make dua...why to wish a luck?
as far as lucky charm, lucky twine, lucky person is concerned that's shirk....means: if we think like...this or that is lucky for me, it can bring be a better luck....lucky locket/chain/ pen...anything thinking that it is gonna bring me a luck...that Shirk and thats haram...
especially, people beleive in stones like rubby/cat-eye/ firoza / sapphire.....using of anything like that and beleiving that...they can bring a better luck that's shirk and Haram...
and Allah know the best.
if you can specify what you tried to say..may be Inshaa'ALlah I'll be able to help you.
Jazakum Allahu Khair
wassalam
I didnt understant what you really said. anyways....if that is to say some one, we can just ask them to make dua...why to wish a luck?
as far as lucky charm, lucky twine, lucky person is concerned that's shirk....means: if we think like...this or that is lucky for me, it can bring be a better luck....lucky locket/chain/ pen...anything thinking that it is gonna bring me a luck...that Shirk and thats haram...
especially, people beleive in stones like rubby/cat-eye/ firoza / sapphire.....using of anything like that and beleiving that...they can bring a better luck that's shirk and Haram...
and Allah know the best.
if you can specify what you tried to say..may be Inshaa'ALlah I'll be able to help you.
Jazakum Allahu Khair
wassalam
thariq2005
Praise be to Allah!
As salaamu 'alaykkum
Luck is like a superstituous thing, and people seem to put their tawakkul on luck as it can widely be seen during exams time or so. It was narrated by Abu Dawood (3910), and al-Tirmidhi (1614) who classed it as saheeh, from Ibn Mas’ood (may Allaah be pleased with him) in a marfoo’ report: “Tiyarah (superstition) is shirk, tiyarah is shirk,” but there is no one among us (who does not feel such things) but Allaah takes it away by means of tawakkul (putting one's trust in Him).
The words “but there is no one among us (who does not feel such things) but Allaah takes it away by means of tawakkul (putting one's trust in Him)” are the words of Ibn Mas’ood, not of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him).
But anyways you can read through the following fatwa, perhaps it explains things better..
Luck is like a superstituous thing, and people seem to put their tawakkul on luck as it can widely be seen during exams time or so. It was narrated by Abu Dawood (3910), and al-Tirmidhi (1614) who classed it as saheeh, from Ibn Mas’ood (may Allaah be pleased with him) in a marfoo’ report: “Tiyarah (superstition) is shirk, tiyarah is shirk,” but there is no one among us (who does not feel such things) but Allaah takes it away by means of tawakkul (putting one's trust in Him).
The words “but there is no one among us (who does not feel such things) but Allaah takes it away by means of tawakkul (putting one's trust in Him)” are the words of Ibn Mas’ood, not of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him).
But anyways you can read through the following fatwa, perhaps it explains things better..
alf2
Islam is a way of life
Good points.
@ bold: My mother in law believes in that...She thinks stones bring certain things. She has them all over her home, including in the corner of each room and above each doorway :astag:
:salam2:
I remember a time when I used to say, "Good luck with that" a lot... but then wanting to change it, it became "Have fun with that" ... lol, now I've realized I use it too often, and sometimes it doesn't quite fit anymore. It's interesting how we add certain 'connotations' to the word luck which we really shouldnt.
I remember a time when I used to say, "Good luck with that" a lot... but then wanting to change it, it became "Have fun with that" ... lol, now I've realized I use it too often, and sometimes it doesn't quite fit anymore. It's interesting how we add certain 'connotations' to the word luck which we really shouldnt.
saifkhan
abd-Allah
Salam alaikum
there is another problem, which is so common and ppl takes it easily, even I have seen many muslims believeing in this: horoscope. its also Shirk. coz ppl might take a look on then in fun, but they get corrupt with it....and they become follower of the one astrologer...even in my country, heres publish books like: monthly instructions for different horoscope and ppl beleive in that and do whatever the books says...eg: what to eat, what to avoid, one can harm, travel will be safe....
astaghfir Allah, these are all Shirk.....please if you have ppl like this around you make them aware...coz commtting Shirk in ignorance also is not a matter of forgiven by ALlah subhanahu wa ta'la
and Allah knows the best
Jazakum Allahu Khair
wassalamu alaikum
there is another problem, which is so common and ppl takes it easily, even I have seen many muslims believeing in this: horoscope. its also Shirk. coz ppl might take a look on then in fun, but they get corrupt with it....and they become follower of the one astrologer...even in my country, heres publish books like: monthly instructions for different horoscope and ppl beleive in that and do whatever the books says...eg: what to eat, what to avoid, one can harm, travel will be safe....
astaghfir Allah, these are all Shirk.....please if you have ppl like this around you make them aware...coz commtting Shirk in ignorance also is not a matter of forgiven by ALlah subhanahu wa ta'la
and Allah knows the best
Jazakum Allahu Khair
wassalamu alaikum
abu'muhammad
Junior Member
Assalaamu alaykum,
Its customary sometimes with people to say “best of luck” during occasions like interviews,exams,travel etc. the usage is ironical as no one first of all know what’s onwards then further telling best for that which is not known ! does it make any sense.
Its customary sometimes with people to say “best of luck” during occasions like interviews,exams,travel etc. the usage is ironical as no one first of all know what’s onwards then further telling best for that which is not known ! does it make any sense.
saifkhan
abd-Allah
Salam Alaikum
Islam has its own way, Islam is the way of life an covering all the aspects...alhamdu li Allah, that's why islam is the only true religion.
It is better to say "Jazakum Allahu Khair"....i'd say it is best to say.....if we have something best, why we go and look for the alternatives? Jaza means the the will and Jazakum Allahu measn by the will of Allah subhanahu wa ta'la, khair means good, so the whole the whole thing is: may everything goes good by the will of Allah subhanahu wa ta'la.....the wishing will also has done and indeed in the best way...we should practise these and hold these things, and Allah subhanahu wa ta'la knows the best
Jazakum Allahu Khair
wassalamu alaikum warahmatu-llah
Islam has its own way, Islam is the way of life an covering all the aspects...alhamdu li Allah, that's why islam is the only true religion.
It is better to say "Jazakum Allahu Khair"....i'd say it is best to say.....if we have something best, why we go and look for the alternatives? Jaza means the the will and Jazakum Allahu measn by the will of Allah subhanahu wa ta'la, khair means good, so the whole the whole thing is: may everything goes good by the will of Allah subhanahu wa ta'la.....the wishing will also has done and indeed in the best way...we should practise these and hold these things, and Allah subhanahu wa ta'la knows the best
Jazakum Allahu Khair
wassalamu alaikum warahmatu-llah
thariq2005
Praise be to Allah!
So it's shirk, and therefore a sin.
Strong statement to say it is shirk. Rather it depends on the person's intention. To be honest it could even be shirk akbar, or shirk asgar, or haraam. It really depends on the person's intention. At the end of day, it is befitting for a believer to place his trust upon Allaah, for if Allaah witholds a certain thing, then none can get hold of it, and if Allaah gives a certain thing to someone, then none can withhold it.
hayat84
I'm not what you believe
:salam2:
Isn't Allah Who decides who will be lucky or not?How can we call the people of the 3rd world who have nothing to eat:aren't they unluckier than us?humanly talking,I may suppose that it would be Haram gambling for luck and wasting money to know about the luck in life or job and so on.This term exists in grammar and we should pay attention to how we use it.using objects as luck bringer is Shirk,but by myself telling good luck to someone may be a good way to make du'a because Allah created everything,Luck too.isn't it?
Isn't Allah Who decides who will be lucky or not?How can we call the people of the 3rd world who have nothing to eat:aren't they unluckier than us?humanly talking,I may suppose that it would be Haram gambling for luck and wasting money to know about the luck in life or job and so on.This term exists in grammar and we should pay attention to how we use it.using objects as luck bringer is Shirk,but by myself telling good luck to someone may be a good way to make du'a because Allah created everything,Luck too.isn't it?