Video Mistakes in Dr. Zakir Naiks Video

[manal09]

First of all this is not to insult Dr. Zakir Naik, I have always loved watching his programs and Masha Allah he does have a good knowledge, but then today a non-muslims showed me this video and said he was fake, I don't know, yes even I can relaise his mistakes here.

This video is in regarding to Evolution and Dr. Zakir Naiks answers to it, but now I'm confused are his lectures reliable? I know there are many controversies arising on his programs...

I want any reasonable answer or advice should I still keep watching Dr. Zakir Naiks videos?

 

[Janaan]

Assalaamu `alaikum warahmatullah, sister.

First of all, a "non-Muslim" lead you to this? That's unquestionably a red-flag, I think. I mean, if you think about it, what exactly are they trying to achieve from showing you a 'refutation' video? They're only out to make him look bad obviously. May Allaah guide us.

Before I say anything else, I'd like to share an image (courtesy of @Seeking Peace lol )

Now that that's out of the way, perhaps you'd like to review this thread where a similar question was asked. http://turntoislam.com/community/threads/question-regarding-dr-zakir-naik.92894/

 

[manal09]

Assalaamu `alaikum warahmatullah, sister.

First of all, a "non-Muslim" lead you to this? That's unquestionably a red-flag, I think. I mean, if you think about it, what exactly are they trying to achieve from showing you a 'refutation' video? They're only out to make him look bad obviously. May Allaah guide us.

Before I say anything else, I'd like to share an image (courtesy of @Seeking Peace lol )

Now that that's out of the way, perhaps you'd like to review this thread where a similar question was asked. http://turntoislam.com/community/threads/question-regarding-dr-zakir-naik.92894/

Jazak Allahu khairan =D i totally understand their point the whole post was like calling Dr. Zakir Naik a taliban or terrorist they mentioned, when I said 'no' they were like.. about the 'Osama' then praised America finally this came up..

true, they should not prove he was a Taliban, so they posted this link to prove he was fake which has no least relevancy!!



PS- I corrected my spellings now :-/ in this comment

 

[Ummah 99]

@manal09
That was a bad call on Dr. Zakir Naik

P.S. The profiles have been changed so you need to update them!

 

[manal09]

@manal09
That was a bad call on Dr. Zakir Naik

P.S. The profiles have been changed so you need to update them!

I did not get you what profiles?

 

[Abu Juwairiya]

First, I agree with what has already been said. Second, the Prophet (SAW) narrated we should remain as one ummah; meaning defend and represent your brothers and sisters, think good of your brethren and remain suspicious of what is said by those outside of our community, namely Non Muslims. Where there is some truth to something, we can accept it but remain with our brothers and sisters. The Prophet (SAW) once remarked he distanced himself from the actions of one follower, but not from the follower himself. If something is truly serious., we can rectify the situation and still think good of our brother/sister while informingt them and others of the error.

 

[Abu Juwairiya]

Manal109, if you believe Zakir Naik has made any mistakes either in his videos, his books, his assertions or otherwise, you can write or contact him and inform him of the specific errors along with the correct information. That way, you can help and support him in an Islamic manner and attain some reward from Allah as well for your contribution to da'wah.