Left long ago
I know you are trying to help but I have noticed something about you..yes you are very educated and smart but at the same time, its almost like your correcting everyone all the time, there is this video on youtube by ummahfilms its called "haram police" it reminds me of you.. I know you just want to help, and maybe im taking it wrong but you should try to do it with a bit more ease..you talk about judgement and critiqueing and to me thats what you are doing.. I hope this did not come out wrong and I hope you and especially Allah forgives me for anything I have done/said wrong.. It is not my in intentions to hurt you or anything, I am very emotional my self.. You also mentioned knowing the duty of ones state.. we dont personally need to know why anyone is doing what they dao thats between them and Allah, if we someone doing wrong maybe a little advice in hopres to guide them to the right path InshAllah
Amar bilmaa'roof and Nahi a'anil Munkir (Advsing good and stopping bad) is the duty of every Muslim which unfortunately we have forgotten. Prophet of Allah SAW had told us that if we stop this then we should wait for a severe punishment (in this world) from Allah.
I always love the posts of sister Muslimah86. She is doing something which prevents nations from the punishment from Allah. I agree with sister Muslimah86 that this would have been better if this same msg could have been sent in PM...then it would have absolutely different meaning.
wa alaikum salam wr wb,