Please help...Bida and what is or are bidas

abjad

AlHamd Li'Laah
thank you.

Ref the pasted post,s(with other scholars Stick threads) i find some their quotation are differing or if i may put it other way

they say- it BIDA reading Kuran to the dead as they usually call (KHITMA)
is it true?

b) i find some other scholars their point is that; which has not been practiced by Nabii Muhammad (saw) is Bida...such as above and say gathering for Maw lid Nabii Mohammad(birthday) (saw)reciting book of "Bar'zanJi"
do teach me please.
 

Itqan Ullah

Time is Running!!
b) i find some other scholars their point is that; which has not been practiced by Nabii Muhammad (saw) is Bida...such as above and say gathering for Maw lid Nabii Mohammad(birthday) (saw)reciting book of "Bar'zanJi"
do teach me please.

Asslamaliekum warahmatullahi wabrakatu,
Yes brother, Celebrating milad-e-nabi/ mawlid is a biddah since its related to deen i.e its an "eid".
You can also refer to these (for a lil more explanation):

[yt]zqNJLXzsnME[/yt]

[yt]JSqpLEVrT80[/yt]

A complete lecture tackling the common biddah:

[yt]DWlSpTwp4Uo[/yt]

Also I'll request you to check out some lectures here: http://www.youtube.com/user/OneWayToParadise/videos

Barakallah feek.
 

abjad

AlHamd Li'Laah
Asslamaliekum,
It serves no useful purpose, a complete waste of time. I have debated with many kinds of people in past and their intention was just to refute, even if it would take them bombarding lies.

I didn't get the purpose of your posting the story though?


there was a question underneath
can you register there?

i have seen an advisable replies as not to; if Lack of Knowledge;
but you and members here to me it seems are well equipped with replies quotation You tube etc; then why not- so you can exercise your ability
of Islamic knowledge
 

Itqan Ullah

Time is Running!!
there was a question underneath
can you register there?
i have seen an advisable replies as not to; if Lack of Knowledge;
:salam2:
I convey the same advise: NO.

but you and members here to me it seems are well equipped with replies quotation You tube etc; then why not- so you can exercise your ability
of Islamic knowledge

Brother, as I said I have tried debating several times they don't want to listen. (not on this forum but on Facebook, etc)
 
Top