Saudi Arabia considers law against insulting Islam

Ron-Kid

HasbunAllahu wa ni`mal Wakil '
cr_mega_708_saudi-shura-council1.jpg


Jeddah: Saudi Arabia is studying new regulations to criminalise insulting Islam, including in social media, and the law could carry heavy penalties, a Saudi paper said on Sunday.

The potential regulations come five months after a Saudi blogger and columnist Hamza Kashgari, 23, was arrested for tweeting comments deemed as insulting the Prophet Mohammad [PBUH]. Kashgari said there were things he liked and disliked about him.
“Within the next two months the Shura Council will reveal the outcome of study on the regulations to combat the criticism of the basic tenets of Islamic Sharia,” unnamed sources with knowledge of the matter told Al Watan, adding that there could be “severe punishments” for violators.

Criticism penalised under the law would include that of the Prophet [PBUH], early Muslim figures and clerics, it said.
“The (regulations) are important at the present time because violations over social networks on the Internet have been observed in the past months,” the sources said.

Blasphemy can be punishable by death.
A spokesman from the Shura Council, the government’s all-appointed consultative body, did not respond to calls for comment.
Kashgari’s case set off a debate in Saudi Arabia, a close US ally for decades and leading world oil exporter, on whether repentance could save convicts from the death penalty.

Kashgari fled the country in February, a few days after his twitter posts, but was later arrested by police in Malaysia en route to New Zealand.

Despite declaring repentance, he was deported back to Saudi Arabia and was taken into police custody to face a trial.
Tension has risen in recent years between religious conservatives and reformers over the pace of gradual political, economic and social reforms in a country with a large young population.

Saudi analyst Jamal Khashoggi said the law required extensive public debate.
“I would rather have this law discussed by the public first. It should not only be debated by the Shura, it should be debated in newspapers first because it can be misused,” Khashoggi said.

“I don’t want anything to affect my freedom and we don’t want Saudi Arabia to be another Iran.”
 

Ron-Kid

HasbunAllahu wa ni`mal Wakil '
yes bro Itqan u r right, Saudi has Shariah implemented but they have it in two parts, like the Rulers [saud family] and the Shura Council. But Saud Family gives out anything when it comes to their interest as an exceptional.

For e.g. I know a person in our local mosque who was a part of Hail Dawah Center in Saudia, he told us that Saudis executed around 25 young guys just coz they were opposing the Saud family of support Americans and letting them exist in the Kingdom, and the reason they gave is that they are not suppose to protest against their rulers based on shariah, and when Shura Council oppose it, the rulers said, we'll answer ALLAH for it, this is Lame and Sick
 

Itqan Ullah

Time is Running!!
o_O

Anyways he's still better than those who permit preaching shirk, shiism,qadyanism,etc to people in name of freedom.
 

Ron-Kid

HasbunAllahu wa ni`mal Wakil '
Exactly, we'll have to understand that the [Islam] TRUTH is one and rest everything [including the so called deviant Jamaats] is evil
 

ShahnazZ

Striving2BeAStranger
What about those that aren't in their right senses? If a mentally ill individual goes around insulting Islam, would they be executed as well?
 

Ron-Kid

HasbunAllahu wa ni`mal Wakil '
What about those that aren't in their right senses? If a mentally ill individual goes around insulting Islam, would they be executed as well?

No sister, if the person is mentally retarded then he/she will not only insults Islam but do something unusual acts in almost all the things and hence there is an exceptional for such people
 

ShahnazZ

Striving2BeAStranger
No sister, if the person is mentally retarded then he/she will not only insults Islam but do something unusual acts in almost all the things and hence there is an exceptional for such people

Mentally disabled individuals may not be obviously so in certain cases. Therefore your statement that their behavior would be accompanied by "unusual behavior" does not always apply, depending on what their diagnosis is. The person would either already have a formal diagnosis or their behavior would be analyzed by professionals and then diagnosed accordingly. At least these are the measures that I believe would definitely be taken when an individual's life is at risk.

Unfortunately many intellectually disabled individuals have been executed for insulting Islam or the Prophet :saw:. At times such cases are not handled the way they should and it seems like people are too eager to kill them, in order to send some kind of message.

Such a law comes with great responsibility. I hope Saudia takes precedence and displays true taqwa while implementing this law by insuring that the perpetrators were of sound mind and health when behaving in such ways.
 

Idris16

Junior Member
What about those that aren't in their right senses? If a mentally ill individual goes around insulting Islam, would they be executed as well?
The Prophet :)saw:) said: “The Pen has been lifted from three: from the sleeper until he awakens, from the child until he reaches puberty and from the insane person until he comes to his senses -- or until he comes round.” Narrated by Abu Dawood (4403), al-Nasaa’i (3432) and Ibn Maajah (2041). Classed as saheeh by Shaykh al-Albaani in Saheeh Abi Dawood.

In al-Mawsoo‘ah al- Fiqhiyyah (16/99) it says, defining insanity:

With regard to (fiqhi) terminology, the fuqaha’ and usooliyyeen defined it in various ways, such as:

It is mental disorder, in such a way that the person cannot do or say things properly, except rarely.

And it was said that insanity is loss of the ability to distinguish between right and wrong or to recognize their consequences.

The author of al-Bahr al-Raa’iq defined it as loss of the ability to understand issues from all angles. End quote.

http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/146375/suicide
 

Mabsoot

Amir
Staff member
The irony is that these people get more publicity and their words are spread all over the world when they are given so much attention.
 
Top