Contradiction explain please?

Ahrms

New Member
Asalaamaleikum.

Allah clearly says in the Quran that he will forgive all sins except shirk. i believe this.

but hadith suggests otherwise?





It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) observed: He who killed himself with steel (weapon) would be the eternal denizen of the Fire of Hell and he would have that weapon in his hand and would be thrusting that in his stomach for ever and ever, he who drank poison and killed himself would sip that in the Fire of Hell where he is doomed for ever and ever; and he who killed himself by falling from (the top of) a mountain would constantly fall in the Fire of Hell and would live there for ever and ever.

however, others have said there are hadith where the prophet pbuh prayed for a sahaba who commited suicide by cutting his wrists?
 

Lavida

New Member
Asalaamaleikum.

Allah clearly says in the Quran that he will forgive all sins except shirk. i believe this.

but hadith suggests otherwise?





It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) observed: He who killed himself with steel (weapon) would be the eternal denizen of the Fire of Hell and he would have that weapon in his hand and would be thrusting that in his stomach for ever and ever, he who drank poison and killed himself would sip that in the Fire of Hell where he is doomed for ever and ever; and he who killed himself by falling from (the top of) a mountain would constantly fall in the Fire of Hell and would live there for ever and ever.

however, others have said there are hadith where the prophet pbuh prayed for a sahaba who commited suicide by cutting his wrists?


From my humble Islamic knowledge, this is their punishment; however, Allah may forgive them. Their sin might be forgiveable. On the other hand, shirk will never be forgiven and Allah knows best.
 
Top