:salam2: subhanallahu khaliq!!!
i cannot believe the amount of backbiting that is going on here? even if he has some defects dont you think its up 2 allah to judge..why do we muslims point out the mistakes of others and not ourselves. if you listen to his lectures they are purely genuine and from the heart and i never once heard himsay something that is dodgy...come on guys its ramdan and you are forking out your knives on another muslim. remeber if you disagree with him about something why dont you write to him and point out his mistakes to him instead of letting other muslims think bad about their brother!! remeber what the prophet said (saw) "i dont want any of you to come up to me and say something about another muslim so that when i see him i think bad of him". have the decency to correct ppl by emailing them and talking to them..i guese all of you know his website. oh and the brother who said that amr khaled shaves his beard..we all make mistakes...did you ever think maybe he doesnt know about that? if you see something bad about ppl you are soppose to correct them not just point it out...and if you hear something bad you are soppose to make 70 excuses for the muslim.
plz take into considerations what i said i am not attacking you i just feel its time we started correcting our mistakes and dwelling on them before accusing others of something.
salaam alikom sisters and brothers
I DIDNT bring anything, and I am not accusing or back bitting him, I have my mistakes BUT did any one of you read what the shiokh said?? or you all just jump to accuse me of attacking brother amr khaild
we need first of all read and listen what the shiokh are saying about this issue, its like you all accusing the shiokh and d3aa of accusing brother Amr Khail. I ma just posting what they said its up to you to listen to the shiokh or not
But dont start accusing me of accusing Brother Amr Khaild. dont get emotional about it.
I knew this the reaction we will get out of this, but no one is back bitting brother Amr Khalid, He is a good person and A LOT of young generation changed thier life by Allah mercy through attending his lectures, But what ever I posted is from a well known shieokh I didnt BROUGHT anything, as I said YES HE was really good at the start but later on he had strange Fatwa's.
A lot of people came back to religion through of Amr Khalid may Allah Reward him inshallah for every good deed these people will do. Do you think any one like to see that shyokh talk about Amr Khalid like this?
They didnt speak out except when they saw something wrong with his Dawah, they have nothing against him, they trying to advise him.
They shiyokh like to advise and when the person dont listen, what you expect them to do? they will have to answer infront of Allah too if they let the mistake go by without correction.
Did any one of you read the linke and what Wajdee Kohneem said: He said that he kept everything in secert between him and amr khalid later on some one LEAKED the letter he sent to Amr Khalid. So NO ONE said anything bad about him the shyokh said good things about him BUT later on most of them changed thier opinion,
beside sisters are ver senstive about this issue, you need to listen to other shiokh too so you know the difference and the words he uses.
Read the link I posted to Islamway.com .. its a really fair site they dont have anything a gainst any one, they might (use to)have Amr khalid lectures too.
But read what Wajdee Kohneem said with open mind.
one of the sister said:
plz take into considerations what i said i am not attacking you i just feel its time we started correcting our mistakes and dwelling on them before accusing others of something.
that what the shiokh trying to do.
I WILL REMOVE THE LINK TO THE NEWS PAPER BUT YOU NEED TO READ WHAT OTHER SHIOKH SAID AND LISTEN WITH OPEN MIND BEFORE YOU START DEFENDING Without listening to the shiokh and what are they saying and why they are saying all this and trying to Advise brother Amr Khalid.
shiokh who talked about his subject
أبو إسحاق الحويني
الشيخ: سعيد عبد العظيم
الشيخ: عبد المنعم الشحات
then lsiten to المفتي :محمد عبدالمقصود[/CENTER]
click here : PLEASE READ AND LISTEN WHAT OTHER DA3AA AND SHIOKH SAID TO CORRECT BROTHER AMR KHAILD[/B]
we all have mistake I am not attacking or saying anything about brother Amr Khalid I am just posting what the other shiokh said. I have my mistakes and Allah know I am not better than any one so dont take what I posted as I dont like or attacking brother Amr Khaild a lot of people speically the young generation changed thier life by Allah mercy then by attending his lectures...........but we need to hear what shiokh saying about this issue now.
ملحوظة: ما قمنا بموقع إذاعة طريق الإسلام بنشر المقال الأول لفضيلة الداعية الشيخ وجدي غنيم إلا من باب الحرص على مصلحة الدعوة والحرص على الأستاذ عمرو خالد نفسه, وما نأمل من نشر الثاني إلا أن يكون خطوة لإصلاح أخطاء وتقدم على طريق الحق, فليس العيب أن نخطئ ولكن العيب كل العيب أن نصر على الأخطاء, وما توفيقي إلا بالله. (مشرف المقالات بموقع طريق الإسلام)
that my opinon too may allah forgive us all
Wa salaam alikom