Is this for real??

A

Abdul Hasib

Student of Knowledge
That is not possible. The only way somone could've been a Chrisitan/Muslim was the time period between Esa (AS) and Muhmmad (SAW). The reason is that some of Esa (AS's) followers beleived that HE ESA (AS) was a prophet, and that another prophet was going to come.

But the word Christian/Muslim doesn't make sense cause Muslims don't beleive that Esa was a Christ. So the best term is "the Muslim followers of Esa."
 
A

Aapa

Mirajmom
Salaam,

Basic problem is intercession. There is no intercession in Islam. If she truly is a Muslim then she can not be a priest. Futhermore, many sects within Christianity do not recognize women as priests. The laying of the hands was a ceremony for men only. I pray she finds peace.
 
kayleigh

kayleigh

Junior Member
Not possible, if for no other reason than you can't be Christian unless you believe the way to get to heaven is to accept Jesus Christ as your savior because he died on the cross for your sins and was the Son of God. That's not the case in Islam.

The only way you can be Muslim and Christian is if you define it not by what religion you believe in or practice, but think of it more as an ethnicity. I have known some people who say that they're half Muslim, half Christian, because their mother was Christian and their father was Muslim. But that doesn't go with the REAL definitions of either faith. I just met a guy the other day who called himself atheist, but insisted he was half Christian and half Muslim because his mother was Muslim and his father was Christian.
 
F

falasteny

Junior Member
salam alaikom
4 me she looks like get confused after spending her life in a church and then discovered islam so she couldnot ignor islam after realising its a true from god and she coudnot releas her self yet from the church so she became this confused ,i think the only thing she needs is to get to know more about islam and she will be a muslim inshallah and as we all knows if god opened her mind to islam that she will end up a muslim but we all know that its not an easy change
 
D

danial

Junior Member
if she had said the shahada, constantly questions the divinity of jesus, believes in the 5 pillars of islam, i dont see why she calls should call herself Christian! I think she probably just doesnt wanna let go of her christianhood where she had a lot of power since she was a priest.

as we've read, she was from a learned family where everyone was interlectually successful. knowing this from her background, i hypothesize that she is the kinda person who enjoys the position of "power". if she was to identify herself to be "totally" muslim, she would have no power anymore. instead, she would just be a member of a big family.

what i am guessing is that power means alot to her n she can only achieve that in xtianity.thats why she doesnt wanna let go of it ALTHOUGH she is a practising muslim.
 
IslamIsLight

IslamIsLight

Islam is my life
Staff member
Or may be the media just add it on,because they are embarrased to say that the Priest of 20 years turned to Islam.Or may be she is from different branch of Christianity.But I think its just all media
 
J

junaid hasan

Banned
i have 2 man infront of me.One of them is my father.

If i say now that they both are my father!

how could it be possible.

i have genetic from one man and its impossible to have from 2 men.

this 2 men are not same also islam and christianty is not same.

If any body accept one god but still busy with the law of prophet jesus(pbuh) or give more responce than others then its will be not accepteable by allah.
 
D

danial

Junior Member
junaid hasan said:
i have 2 man infront of me.One of them is my father.

If i say now that they both are my father!

how could it be possible.

i have genetic from one man and its impossible to have from 2 men.

this 2 men are not same also islam and christianty is not same.

If any body accept one god but still busy with the law of prophet jesus(pbuh) or give more responce than others then its will be not accepteable by allah.
Click to expand...

lol! thats a bad example. one can say that one is the biological father while the other is the man hu raised you. ie step father
 
J

junaid hasan

Banned
danial said:
lol! thats a bad example. one can say that one is the biological father while the other is the man hu raised you. ie step father
Click to expand...


sorry brother my english is poor so i was not able to use right words.I have just tried to write the meaning of original relation.

*apologies*

:astag:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top