questions concerning islam...

Q

questionnaire

New Member
SALAM ALIKOM

i have a question, so i would apreciate it if you could help me.

if the Quran is right, and bible is wrong.

If the quran never mentions the corruption of the previous scriptures and if it contradicts it,doesnt that mean that quran itself is wrong?

so it means that maybe they were also the words of Allah(swt) but ALLAH did not take their responsibility??!!

This shows that ALlah is a dishonest and inconsistent God.Why didn't he save his previous revelations and allowed billions of people to be deceived.And if this is so,why is he protecting the quran?
Im asking a straight forward question,why didnt allah save the previous books and he is now saving the quran??????????????

thank you.
________________________
 
ShyHijabi

ShyHijabi

Junior Member
If the quran never mentions the corruption of the previous scriptures and if it contradicts it,doesnt that mean that quran itself is wrong?
Click to expand...

Actually corruption of the previous scriptures is mentioned numerous time. The Quran shows Jesus (pbuh) was made a deity and this was a corruption of his mission. There are many more but this stands out to me the most. Also there is a direct contradiction when the "old testament" states that Abraham (pbuh) was called upon to sacrifice his only son when this is patently false. The bible states previously that he had Ishmael (pbuh) before Isaac (pbuh). This is a glaring contradiction that the Judeo/Christian scholars remain silent on.


This shows that ALlah is a dishonest and inconsistent God.Why didn't he save his previous revelations and allowed billions of people to be deceived.And if this is so,why is he protecting the quran?
Im asking a straight forward question,why didnt allah save the previous books and he is now saving the quran??????????????
Click to expand...

I disagree with the assertion that the corruption of the original scriputes reveals that Allah swt is deceitful, it does speak volumes for the deceit and corruption of man though. We have free will and thus are capable of great evil. And people have tried to corrupt the Quran, look at Nation of Islam, the Shia, and the Mohammedians...they just haven't been very successful yet.

However it is prophesized that in the last days there will not a Quran anymore, that no one will remember it's pages and that best of humans will only be able to say "The is only One God." Allah swt is merciful and therefore continuosly has revealed the truth only to have humans twist it all up. He sent thousands of prophets to us to put us on the straight path but we stupidly drift back to ignorance.

So you see...the revelations being made over and over again show patience and mercy to us, despite the many times we have tried to distort it throughout history.

Wasalaam

~Sarah
 
E

__Enslaved___

Junior Member
questionnaire said:
SALAM ALIKOM

i have a question, so i would apreciate it if you could help me.

if the Quran is right, and bible is wrong.

If the quran never mentions the corruption of the previous scriptures and if it contradicts it,doesnt that mean that quran itself is wrong?

so it means that maybe they were also the words of Allah(swt) but ALLAH did not take their responsibility??!!

This shows that ALlah is a dishonest and inconsistent God.Why didn't he save his previous revelations and allowed billions of people to be deceived.And if this is so,why is he protecting the quran?
Im asking a straight forward question,why didnt allah save the previous books and he is now saving the quran??????????????

thank you.
________________________
Click to expand...


selaam

The books like the injiil(gospel) were a bunch of books comprised by the romans that used to be pagans.

Christinaity today follows a bunch of sects and versions of christianity. They argue and fight with eachother and don't really know which is the right one. A major sect of CHristianity today is Roman Catholisism the christianity taught by the Apostle Paul of Tarsus adopted by the romans.

After the pagan romans converted to christianity, they sought out to destroy any other forms of christianity in their conquered lands that did not compel with their beliefs. They established many inquisitions to so call purify christianity. Any beleifs that did not go with the christianity of rome were known as heretics and were doomed to be destroyed. It is important to note that many believe that that the words like Trinity came much after Jesus's(by whom be peace) asension into heaven. Many believe that before the time of Paul of Tarsus their could have been other sects of Christianity in the lands of the romans that did not Blasphisize The Creators name and followed Jesus's(by whom be peace) religion properly.

You are asking many questions doubting The Creator of the Universes Glory but what you should be asking yourself is: Why should Allaah(subhanahu wa ta'ala) waste his time to preserve those that have strayed from The Path( like the cHristians) ???
Why should He preserve a system of ideologies(like christianity) which says so many lies about Him, Most Exalted?????
Why should He preserve false prophets who lie about The Creator?????
[/I

When people have gone soooo far astray it probably was best to send a whole new Messenger so that they can come back on the straight path.


Allaah(subhanahu wa ta'ala) sent Jesus(by whom be peace) a true messenger and prophet. He taught them true and pure Islam(submission).....However then they went astray :astag::astag:. Therefore we believe to get people back on the Straight path He, the Creator sent Muhammed(a'aleyhi es-selaam) to purify any corruption.


wa selaam
 
C

cmelbouzaidi

Junior Member
The original Gospels and Psalms of David and the Torah are amongst the Holy Scriptures that Muslims believe in as well as the Qur'an. Are you going to try and fault the faultless Creator, Allah, for allowing man to have intellect to use how he thinks fit? Is it Allah's fault if people changed the Gospels long after Jesus died?

Also, the word bible did not appear on the scene until centuries after Jesus and comes from the Greek word, Byblos.

It is the beauty of the miracle of the Qur'an that the Qur'an we read today is the same as was the true word of Allah, as revealed to Prophet Mohammed, via the Angel Gabriel. Whether you are sitting in Bosnia, Saudi Arabia, Florida or Singapore, the Qur'an, in Arabic, is exactly the same, with not a vowel changed, Alhamdulillah (Praise be to God).
 
Abu Abdillah

Abu Abdillah

Super Moderator
Staff member
questionnaire said:
SALAM ALIKOM

i have a question, so i would apreciate it if you could help me.

if the Quran is right, and bible is wrong.

If the quran never mentions the corruption of the previous scriptures and if it contradicts it,doesnt that mean that quran itself is wrong?

so it means that maybe they were also the words of Allah(swt) but ALLAH did not take their responsibility??!!

This shows that ALlah is a dishonest and inconsistent God.Why didn't he save his previous revelations and allowed billions of people to be deceived.And if this is so,why is he protecting the quran?
Im asking a straight forward question,why didnt allah save the previous books and he is now saving the quran??????????????

thank you.
________________________
Click to expand...

Hi questionnaire,

You ask a question, then you seem to answer it. without waiting for a responce from us here?

its from good ettiquettes in asking a question to await for a reply and an answer, and is very rude to give an answer before hearing the answer.

To get an idea of your back ground, could you please let us know the religion you follow or some idea so we can give you a more direct and prescise answer.

Do You believe in Allah, And the previous Prophets that were sent, Jesus, Moses, Abraham etc..

You ask a question, then you seem to answer it. without waiting for a reply from us here?

Your way of thinking is not correct, you jump to conclusion without even awaiting a reply.

Anyway the previous scriptures are not the words of Allah, you just assume they are, and you just assume they are but you are NOT correct you know very well that the bible for example has many writers he never promised to protect them as he did for his own words which is the Quran

The Quran is the final scripture so the final messge is protected from corruption and therefore no need a another scripture. Also Prophet Muhaamd is the Final Messenger sent.

The Messaage is same for all The Prophets ->>> Your Lord is ONE
do not make images of your Lord remember the commandments that Moses received?
 
A

aj5047

New Member
questionnaire said:
If the quran never mentions the corruption of the previous scriptures
Click to expand...
There are many mentions of the corruption of previous scriptures in the quran. Few examples:
"And they do not assign to Allah the attributes due to Him when they say: Allah has not revealed anything to a mortal. Say: Who revealed the Book which Musa (Moses) brought, a light and a guidance to men, which you make into scattered writings which you show while you conceal much? And you were taught what you did not know, (neither) you nor your fathers. Say: Allah then leave them sporting in their vain discourses." 6:91
"Do you then hope that they (jews) would believe in you, and a party from among them indeed used to hear the Word of Allah, then altered it after they had understood it, and they know (this)." 2:75
"Woe, then, to those who write the book with their hands and then say: This is from Allah, so that they may take for it a small price; therefore woe to them for what their hands have written and woe to them for what they earn." 2:79
questionnaire said:
if it contradicts it
Click to expand...
The quran contradicts the wrong in the previous scriptures to show people the straight path, where there are no lies.
"O followers of the Book! indeed Our Messenger has come to you making clear to you much of what you concealed of the Book and passing over much; indeed, there has come to you light and a clear Book from Allah; with it Allah guides him who will follow His pleasure into the ways of safety and brings them out of utter darkness into light by His will and guides them to the right path." 5: 15-16
questionnaire said:
why didnt allah save the previous books and he is now saving the quran??????????????
Click to expand...
Because Muhammad :saw: is Allah's last messenger & prophet to mankind. In the past, when people went astray from the teachings of a prophet, Allah sent them another prophet to guide them back to the truth. But since this is the last revelation, Allah has promised to keep it as it is and without corruption:
"We have, without doubt, sent down the Message; and We will assuredly guard it (from corruption)." 15:9
The quran is protected from corruption so that people will always find a way back to the Almighty.
questionnaire said:
thank you.
Click to expand...
:SMILY206:
 
Zaynab123

Zaynab123

Subhana Allah!
subhana Allah

:bismillah1:
in the name of Allah the most merciful the compasionate.
asalamu alaykum

no one said the bible is wrong the bible has some true words that are from the quran and it was first copied by someone. you can tell that the bible was written by a man you can never find the word " bible" in the bible but the word quran you find it in the quran if you read the quran. the quran conferns the message of jesus the and the other prophets. you know if you read the bible you can`t find a verse that say Jeusus himself said he was god or the son of.
The word Bible comes from the Greek word "Biblos," which is translated "book." The original manuscripts of the Bible were kept in the synagogues. Those who had custody of the manuscripts first used the Greek word to describe the collection, which later became known as "the Book."
Allah won`t save the quran at the end of the world whenever that is. like sister sarah said no one will know quran at the end of the world. subhana Allah may Allah save us from that day.
so please don`t say Allah is dishonest. and you should know that evey other book was from him. he send all those books to humans like us and quran is to us. we should not waste the only time we have becoz when our chances are over. we get our rewards wether it is bad or good. we will always get what we deserve.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top