The Prison Population in America; An Analysis

Abu Juwairiya

Junior Member
"Over the past three decades, this 'black flower' [Prison] has proliferated in the United States as the country has built a carceral state that is unprecedented among Western countries and in U.S. history.

Three features distinguish the U.S. carceral state: the sheer size of its prison and jail population; its reliance on harsh, degrading sanctions; and the persistence and centrality of the death penalty.

Nearly one in fifty people in the United States, excluding children and the elderly, is behind bars today.
In a period dominated by calls to roll back the state in all areas of social and economic policy,
we have witnessed a massive expansion of the state in the realm of penal policy.

The U.S incarceration rate has accelerated dramatically, increasing more than fivefold since 1973. Today a higher proportion of the adult population in the United States is behind bars than anywhere else in the world.

The United States, with 5 per cent of the world’s population, has nearly a quarter of its prisoners. America’s incarceration rate of 714 per 100,000 is five to twelve times the rate of Western European countries and Japan.

Even after taking into account important qualifications in the use of the standard 100, 000 yardstick to compare incarceration rates cross-nationally, the United States is still off the charts.

The reach of the U.S. penal state extends far beyond the 2.2 million men and women who are now serving time in prison or jail in America.

On any given day, nearly seven million people are under the supervision of the correctional system, including jail, prison, parole, probation, and other community supervision sanctions.

This constitutes 3.2 per cent of the US adult population, or one in every thirty-two adults, a rate of state supervision that is unprecedented in U.S history.

If one adds up the total number of people in prison, plus paroles, probationers, employees of correctional institutions, close relatives of prisoners and correctional employees, and residents in communities where jails and prisons are major employers, tens of millions of people are directly affected each day by the carceral state.

These overall figures on incarceration belie the enormous and disproportionate impact that this bold and unprecedented social experiment has had on certain groups in U.S. society, especially young African Americans, Hispanics, and the growing number of incarcerated women who are parents of young children.

Blacks, who make up less than 13 per cent of the U.S population, now comprise more than half of all people in prison, up from a third twenty years ago and from a quarter in the late 1930s.

The number of black men in prison or jail has grown so rapidly over the past quarter-century that today more black men are behind bars than are enrolled in colleges and universities.

Unlike other major state-building exercises like the New Deal and the Great Society, the construction of the carceral state was not presented as a package of policies for public debate. The carceral state was built up rapidly over the past thirty years largely outside of the public eye and not necessarily planned out. While the explosion in the size of the prison population and the retributive turn in U.S. penal policy are well documented, the underlying political causes of this massive expansion are not well understood.

Clearly, why the United States created such an extensive and punitive penal state is a complex question. Penal policies and institutions are formed not from a single factor, but instead by a whole range of converging forces. Still, it is important to sort out the more important from the less important factors....

Specifically, why didn’t the rise of the carceral state face more political opposition? The absence of such opposition, as will be shown, provided permissive conditions for political elites to construct a massive penal system.

Explanations for the rise of the carceral state vary enormously, but many of them do have one thing in common. They adopt a relatively short time frame as they try to identify what changed in the United States over the past thirty to forty years to disrupt its relatively stable and unexceptional incarceration rate and to bring back capital punishment with a vengeance.

The half-dozen major explanations – an escalating crime rate, shifts in public opinion, the war on drugs, the emergence of the prison-industrial complex, changes in American political culture, and politicians exploiting the law-and-order issue for electoral gain – concentrate on developments since the 1960s,"
(Source: "The Prison and the Gallows: The Politics of Mass Incarceration in America' By Marie Gottschalk, P 1-2, 2006)
 

Abu Juwairiya

Junior Member
Are most of the prisoners muslim? Just a little confused about the connection to Islam.

I'm sorry for not stating earlier, the Muslim population in incarceration in the US, is like some other ethnic minorities in the US, especially the black males, increasing year by year. This includes both those with Muslim backgrounds in addition to the two types of reverts (i.e. those who are Muslim before arrest and the second who embrace Islam after entering prison). Hence the Muslim prisoner is among the new persecuted groups with a growth in the limitation of rights and greater controls because of the image and label of 'terrorism' attached to all Muslim inmates across the country.

I wanted to make readers develop some understanding of the kind of prison environment, prison culture and perception of prison that exists in the US and how it effects both the general American population (for one reason or another) and the globe, since the proliferation of powers given to the President is further ensuring more and more innocent people will end up there and remain for years to come.
 

Precious Star

Junior Member
Any info on how prisons are run in muslim countries, do they comply with the Islamic concepts of justice, and are women treated with respect? I think that would be very useful, too.
Does anyone reading this know?
 

Abu Juwairiya

Junior Member
Are most of the prisoners muslim? Just a little confused about the connection to Islam.
Any info on how prisons are run in muslim countries, do they comply with the Islamic concepts of justice, and are women treated with respect? I think that would be very useful, too.
Does anyone reading this know?

You can read the book, 'Tyrants, the world's 20 worst living dictators' by David Wallechinsky. While it is not strictly about prison, it details some insights into the justice system of some Muslim countries and the exclusion of Shariah and Islamic precepts from the executive system and legislature.

The most significant entry includes Islam Karimov [the current President] of Uzbekistan, which is the most comprehensive and specific about legal redress, the constitution, freedom and erosion of civil liberties.

Other Muslim countries mentioned, but with a lot less emphasis on prison and prison conditions and a great deal on the image and notoriety of the leaders and their ideologies include Qadaffi of Libya, Sudan, Pakistan [a little scarcity of information here on what you are looking for], Bashar Al Assad of Syria, Iran, Saudi Arabia and Turkmenistan.

If you do choose to read the book, you may also find the last entry, 'A Special Case: George W Bush [Jr.]- United States of America', placed outside of the immediate twenty worst dictators, but nevertheless included in the book as a 'tyrant', interesting and revealing as well. I wish you well in your research.
 

Abu Juwairiya

Junior Member
There are other published material that deal with the same subject as an additional theme to the principal content. They include-

1. The Politics of Human Rights in Asia by Kenneth Christy and Denny Roy.

This book speaks about Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia. It focusses on economy, history and the political situation. However, there are passages on their own that deal with justice, the criminal system and human rights.

2. Human Rights Watch Report (Annual Editions) address all countries records and include themes related to torture, justice, legal and constitutional rights.

3. 'Just Five Minutes: Nine Years in the Prisons of Syria' by Heba Dabagh might be more interesting as it is a biographical account of the author's experiences in jail (before the Civil War).

4. 'Crime Against Humanity: Indict Iran's Ruling Mullahs for massacre of 30, 000 political prisoners' by the National Council of Resistance of Iran' while specific to its title, contains some information that you may find of interest.
 

Abu Juwairiya

Junior Member
The enclosed book is principally about global torture, but includes aspects of similar themes, namely treatment of prisoners [excluding torture of course], limitations of justice and a few other things. Several Muslim countries are mentioned along with their favourite methods of torture .
 

Attachments

  • Torture and Democracy By Darius Rejali [Excellent].pdf
    3.2 MB · Views: 0

Abu Juwairiya

Junior Member
You can also obtain the book, 'Return of the Pharaoh' by Zeinab Al Ghazali. She was a member of the Ikhwanul Muslimeen (Muslim Brotherhood) under the leadership of Sayyed Qutub in Egypt and spent many years in prison for her activism.

Although the book is quite old, her prison experiences and individual case (along with other members of MB at the time) with the justice system are quite vivid and revealing. Its further interesting that from what others have said about Egyptian style of justice, the courts system, the authoritarian and draconian methods used to extract forced confessions, threat of and actual rape and other forms of police brutality are still largely the same, if anything they have progressively become worse over time. This is despite the fact, Zeinab Al Ghazali was arrested in the 1960s and her experiences are of that time, over fifty years ago.
 
Top