Cuma Prayer

[Killi_Feyzo]

Salamun Aleikum wa rahmatullah wa barakhatu,

i have a question
after we pray with the imam we normally pray immediately sunnah

someone told me that this is not right
we are not allowed to pray right after fard
how is this described in the sunnah of the prophet (sas)

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

So no clue?

 

[Abu Talib]

Wa`alaykumassalam Warahmatullahi Wabarakatu


Ofcourse you can pray sunnah after Fard salaah who denies that but its better to make the prescribed Dhikr after salaah then pray Sunnah.

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

allright because he argued that it isnt allowed to pray right after fard without talking or leaving the mosque...

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

Barakullah feekum

So it will Be better if i make dhikr after the prayer or i Change the Place and pray sunnah two rows behind

I have another question concerning the cuma prayer or generally communal prayer
In my masjid everyone make the taslim together
So if the Imam says asalamun aleikum wa rahmatullah and put His Head to the right we all follow him until He says it another Time and when He Repeats we follow him again
But i saw that for example in Mekka they do Not so this
Everyone Males tasleem for himself
Are both versions ok?

 

[Seeking Allah's Mercy]

allright because he argued that it isnt allowed to pray right after fard without talking or leaving the mosque...

So it will Be better if i make dhikr after the prayer or i Change the Place and pray sunnah two rows behind

Asalamoalaikom wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatuhu. . .

Do they have evidence for this? I mean I've never heard changing places or doing Dhikr must after fardh or of any such thing. I do recite Ayah Al kursi after fardh never heard this being a "must" or even "preffered" act.

Barakullah feekum

I have another question concerning the cuma prayer or generally communal prayer
In my masjid everyone make the taslim together
So if the Imam says asalamun aleikum wa rahmatullah and put His Head to the right we all follow him until He says it another Time and when He Repeats we follow him again
But i saw that for example in Mekka they do Not so this
Everyone Males tasleem for himself
Are both versions ok?

The Imaam is to be followed. They follow him in Makkah too. I guess you confused how some perform tasleem as the Imaam does it and others do it when the Muaddhin (?)repeats after the Imaam. It's because the Imaam's voice is sometimes not reaching everyone in Haram. So the takbeers and tasleem etc. are repeated for everyones benefit.

Some one correct me if I am wrong please. Jazakallah khair.

 

[Abu Talib]

Assalamu`alaykum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatu

Read this brother

When is it prescribed for the person praying behind the imam to say the tasleem to his right?
When saying tasleem at the end of prayer, should the person who is praying behind an imam say tasleem after the first tasleem from the imam, then the second after the second, or should he wait and not say the tasleem until the imam has finished the second tasleem?
_______________________________________________________

Praise be to Allaah.

It is better for the person who is praying behind an imam not to say the tasleem at the end of the prayer until the imam has finished the second tasleem.

Al-Nawawi (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in al-Majmoo’ (3/464):

Al-Baghawi said: It is mustahabb not to start the salaam until the imam has finished both tasleems. This is the view of al-Shaafa’i according to al-Buwayti, as was quoted by al-Baghawi. He said: Whoever is (praying) behind an imam, when the imam has finished his salaam, he should say salaam to his right and his left. End quote.

Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in al-Sharh al-Mumti’ (4/267):

The scholars said: It is makrooh to say the first and second tasleem with your imam, but if you say the first tasleem after his first tasleem and the second tasleem after his second tasleem, there is nothing wrong with that, but it is better not to say the tasleem until after he has said both tasleems. End quote.

And Allaah knows best.

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

i have observed something strange today

the imam said after he finished his first khutba

al fatiha
and everyone raised their hands and started reciting al fateha and some (allahuma sali allah muhammad...)

is this from sunnah?

 

[thariq2005]

i have observed something strange today

the imam said after he finished his first khutba

al fatiha
and everyone raised their hands and started reciting al fateha and some (allahuma sali allah muhammad...)

is this from sunnah?

No it is not- BaarakAllaahu feek

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

I slowly think that my mosque is the King of Bidah

After the sunnah prayer everybody make dhikr where a caller says loudly subhanallah and everybody makes dhikr and so on...

After that the imam raises his Hand and everybody is Making dua with the Imam

This isnt from sunnah right?

And after the Imam Finish his khutba He raises his Hand and makes dua loudly do we have to say ameen there?

Barakullah feekum

 

[Hearts of Greenbirds]

let me aske you a Q akhi
when your imam say so and so why dont you aske for prove / Dalil
why do you keep getting Confused ,, ?? my advice to you would be next time aske for Dalil ,, and you wont go wrong this time
and dont rush on saying my masjid is a Bidah it dependt on what they follow as a masjid and what they stand for ,,, right me if i am wrong Barakallah feekum

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

the masjid where i got is a turkey masjid
and i do not speak turkey so i do not understand what they are talking about
there is no masjid in my surrounding in my language
allahualim

i dont know what they stand for but if there actions are bidah what should i call them sunnah?

 

[Seeker-of-truth]

Assalaamualaikum warahmatullahi wa barakaatuh,

Turkey is a country where there is great bid'ah which comes from the Naqshabandi sufi's. it is them that have these weird dhikr gatherings and other celebrations that arent from the sunnah. From what your saying it definitely sounds like them.

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

well they are not sufis
they might have some mistakes but is is better than having no mosque...
but by now i do not enjoy praying there anymore...

 

[Killi_Feyzo]

i always pray 4 rakat sunnah before cuma and after cuma, but i have read that only the hanafi madhab is doing this

i do not follow any madhab
i just follow quran and sunnah and the strongest opinion between the ulama

so does someone know what is the strongest opinion between the ulama about this issue?