Response: You have not refuted anything. You do not have any ancient Arabic writings from the time of the Prophet or as even as early as within the first century after the time of the Prophet in which the word khimar is used only to refer to covering the head or hair. Where is it? You provided nothing.
Nor did you provide any evidence that a head cover was commonly worn during the Prophet’s life or even a century after his death, nor any reliable chain of narrators going back to the first 4 Caliphs of Islam that ever document or report any dispute or issue they had with the Muslims regarding the fact that they did not wear the head cover all this time. Thus supporting the fact that both history and Islamic sources proves that the head cover is NOT mandatory in Islam. It is a cultural practice.
This has turned out to be as baseless and futile argument as you'll ever see!
This logic logic isn't my thing for "...Islam isn't based on logic and philosophy..."( From Ali Ibn Talib's words)... but I did not see your logic any where... I'm sorry(I hate telling this truth) your posts have neither logic nor nobility! So hypocritical that I can hardly bear... ( because you accuse me of not using logic and yet ask me to provide text and evidence to prove my case! Hypocrisy at work!)
Read the original post, see the Qur'anic verses! Help yourself! See the Ahadith quoted in the original two posts! See the one about Ansaar woman in particular!... read the posts that follow! And Help your self!
besides being so extreme in views @Al-Fatihah you're very arrogant! Arrogance is all I see from the manner you reply...
I wrote a long post,you ignored it completely...then I wrote another one and you replied to the first paragraph(ignoring the last paragraphs which are the most important and reasoning-based)
Arrogance is when you're self-centric... And I'm sorry arrogance made you disregard what others are posting!
I'm not arrogant neither is anyone else apart from you because I replied to you point by point, not belittling any of your points!
So I rest my case!( my final reply to someone blind following a piece of work which he saw on the Internet and fell in love with_ this headcover issue isn't your work, we both know that! you fell in love with this idea from Internet and you're taking it every where to justify and meet your day to day life)