Saleem where are you from?
:salam2:I was Born in Pakistan, Came to America When I was a child with my Parents. And have no Intention of staying here any longer.
Saleem where are you from?
There is no ikhtilaf on this issue, all the scholars agree on this and I already posted the fatawah in my first post, so like I said earlier either you take it or leave case closed. no need to post anything else.
Islamonline.com is not a source that we muslims can take from because many of them from islamonline are Ikwanies and their leader Yusuf al-qaradawi has many grave mistakes in his belief which shiekh Utaymeen spoke about it. I'm not going to take the topic in tangents and speak about this Individual, but Just read the fatawah from Islam-qa which I posted like I said and you will get your answer. No need to post anything else. barak Allahu feek
And Mumin01 Yasir Qadhi is not a Scholar of Islam matter of fact there are no Muslim scholars living in the west, so what he has to say doesn't have any weight to what I posted. And so please refrain from dragging the issue any further when I already Posted the answer for this issue in my first post. Barak Allahu Feek
If you disagree with anything know that none of here are scholars and we shouldn't give our own opinion Unless we have Evidence from Authentic Sources and Scholars who are actually from Ahlul Sunnah. Jazak'Allahu Khairan
No need to drag this Issue any further the evidence is already posted, So take it or Leave.
Jazak'Allahu Khairan
As-Salaam 3laikum Wa Ra7matullahi Wabarakatu
salam aleikum
Im sorry to say that ,but I really hate to hear when people start judging others ,no scholars on the West ok let me agree ,but they do no not call themselves scholars .Yasir Qadi never said he is a scholar.We dont have scholars here in Us ,but alhamdulillah we still have many great people who are giving their lives in giving dawah and calling people to Islam .They are not scholars but lets not point fingers at them ,as only Allah SWT can judge them..
About immigrating to muslim country I dont want argue on this issue,but where is a muslim country ?does it exist at all? Will saudia,the only country I would call islamic , accept me to live there if Im not arab? who will pay for my ticket to go to muslim country ? who will work for me there and help me to survive ? Lets all immigrate, sure ,but how? .Lets be realistic.....
And who garantee me I wont be second class if I live in Muslim country .If Im russian not arab ,wont I be looked down upon there? Many muslim lands are full of shirk,alhamdulillah I found Islam here .I have no problem practicing my religion and I can call people to Allah here ...Im here because I dont have choice but still if I had a choice I would go and live in a muslim land ,however it is ...Many people think that muslims leaving there lands because they want money,thats why they live in a kafir countries and that to live here is a Paradise ,well its completely wrong thinking ...
Many muslims live here not because of money or the comfort of life ,but because they start learning their religion here and practice it .Sounds strange but its true..
waaleikum salam
:salam2:
Conclusions:
What all this amounts to is that there is flexibility in the matter. If a Muslim feels the need to live in a Muslim country where he can practice his religion with greater freedom and comfort, then it is a good thing for him to do so if he gets the opportunity. However, if he finds it better for him to stay where he is, then he is free to do so. As long as he is free to practice his faith, then he may stay in his country. We might add another consideration that he must take into account: He should be able to raise his children as Muslims.
And Allah knows best.
:salam2:
salam aleikum
.Lets be realistic.....
And who garantee me I wont be second class if I live in Muslim country .If Im russian not arab ,wont I be looked down upon there? Many muslim lands are full of shirk,alhamdulillah I found Islam here .I have no problem practicing my religion and I can call people to Allah here ...Im here because I dont have choice but still if I had a choice I would go and live in a muslim land ,however it is ...Many people think that muslims leaving there lands because they want money,thats why they live in a kafir countries and that to live here is a Paradise ,well its completely wrong thinking ...
Live here first and then talk and judge those who live here...
waaleikum salam
salam aleikum
About immigrating to muslim country I dont want argue on this issue,but where is a muslim country ?does it exist at all? Will saudia,the only country I would call islamic , accept me to live there if Im not arab? who will pay for my ticket to go to muslim country ? who will work for me there and help me to survive ? Lets all immigrate, sure ,but how? .Lets be realistic.....