who can solve this *salah* puzzle?

ahmed_indian

ahmed_indian

to Allah we belong
:salam2:

i found this in other Islamic forum.:)

How do you pray a "salah" in which you will sit four times for tashahhud?

hint: this salah is very usual and common.

sorry if i cannot explain it properly.:(
 
Muslim_Gurl

Muslim_Gurl

Thank You Allah!
ahmed_indian said:
:salam2:

i found this in other Islamic forum.:)

How do you pray a "salah" in which you will sit four times for tashahhud?

hint: this salah is very usual and common.

sorry if i cannot explain it properly.:(
Click to expand...

You make four times Tashahhud when your not concentrating in prayer, and you make this mistake :p Im kidding :p

I don't know, I've never heard of this...
 
Tabassum07

Tabassum07

Smile for Allah
I know the answer to it, but I've forgotten. Its something where a person is late for maghrib fard, and he enters it after ruku when the imam is in the second rakah.


So the person joins the imam and sits with their tashahhud (T-1), and then he sits with the imam in the third rakat tashahhud (T-2), this is the person's first rakat. Then the imam says salaam, but the person gets up and prays his second rakat, so he sits again for tashahhud (T-3). Then, he gets up for his third rakat, and therefore sits for his fourth tashahhud (T-4).

I know I explained very badly, but try to understand!
 
arzafar

arzafar

Junior Member
Tabassum07 said:
I know the answer to it, but I've forgotten. Its something where a person is late for maghrib fard, and he enters it after ruku when the imam is in the second rakah.


So the person joins the imam and sits with their tashahhud (T-1), and then he sits with the imam in the third rakat tashahhud (T-2), this is the person's first rakat. Then the imam says salaam, but the person gets up and prays his second rakat, so he sits again for tashahhud (T-3). Then, he gets up for his third rakat, and therefore sits for his fourth tashahhud (T-4).

I know I explained very badly, but try to understand!
Click to expand...

i think you're correct bro
 
slaveofAllah88

slaveofAllah88

Slave of Allah (swt)
ahmed_indian said:
:salam2:

i found this in other Islamic forum.:)

How do you pray a "salah" in which you will sit four times for tashahhud?

hint: this salah is very usual and common.

sorry if i cannot explain it properly.:(
Click to expand...

:salam2:

bhai wouldn't that be a 8 rakaat salaat so i would say taraweeh

:) lol now im curious i hope u tell the answer soon :)
 
Summer03

Summer03

3doTs2sQuares
Salam!

Ooh I rmmbr asking this question in Ramadan lol

brother tariq2005 got it right... Here's what he said:
"As salamu alaikkum. The man must have joined the congregation during Maghrib after the imaam came up from ruku' so that way he does not get that raka, yet the man will sit in tashahud. Later when the imaam comes to the third raka', he will sit in tashahud during that raka', but that will be the first raka' for the man who joined. So he sat 2 tashahud already. After the taslim is done by the imaam, the man will stand up and complete the maghrib salah by praying 2 last rakahs with 2 more tashahuds, making a total of 4 tashahud"
 
thariq2005

thariq2005

Praise be to Allah!
Summer03 said:
Salam!

Ooh I rmmbr asking this question in Ramadan lol

brother tariq2005 got it right... Here's what he said:
"As salamu alaikkum. The man must have joined the congregation during Maghrib after the imaam came up from ruku' so that way he does not get that raka, yet the man will sit in tashahud. Later when the imaam comes to the third raka', he will sit in tashahud during that raka', but that will be the first raka' for the man who joined. So he sat 2 tashahud already. After the taslim is done by the imaam, the man will stand up and complete the maghrib salah by praying 2 last rakahs with 2 more tashahuds, making a total of 4 tashahud"
Click to expand...

wa 'alaikkumus salaam wa rahmathullah, ma shaAllah sister you still remember i got it right ;) Its probably the first puzzle i got right lol. I was thinking of other answers like taraweeh, but I came to realize that every 2 rakat is seperated by a tasleem, and thus the prayer is seperate. Because Taraweeh can be even 20 rakaats so thats literally 10 tashaahudS :p

Anyhoo only the maghrib salah one made sense to me :)

Wa salaamu 'alaikkum
 
Summer03

Summer03

3doTs2sQuares
Salam everyone.

Those saying it can be other prayers...please show us how.

Those saying taraweeh, well it can't be becuase obviously it's a tasleem after every two rakah, and there is no possibility of it being that. It's one prayer, but the riddle wouldn't make sense.

And the original wording of the riddle goes like
this ... A man sat four times for tashahud in one prayer, how so?

So it's one complete prayer. Taraweeh can consist of two rakahs only, so the riddle wouldn't apply with it if people choose to answer that way.
 
Summer03

Summer03

3doTs2sQuares
thariq2005 said:
wa 'alaikkumus salaam wa rahmathullah, ma shaAllah sister you still remember i got it right ;) Its probably the first puzzle i got right lol. I was thinking of other answers like taraweeh, but I came to realize that every 2 rakat is seperated by a tasleem, and thus the prayer is seperate. Because Taraweeh can be even 20 rakaats so thats literally 10 tashaahudS :p

Anyhoo only the maghrib salah one made sense to me :)

Wa salaamu 'alaikkum
Click to expand...

Salam

Lol that's how awesome copy and paste is!
 
Tabassum07

Tabassum07

Smile for Allah
No way, I got it right too, is my answer invisible or something? :angryred: :angryblue: :tantrum1:

Just kidding. Please post up more riddles like this!
 
Summer03

Summer03

3doTs2sQuares
ayman1 said:
If what you're saying is correct then you're saying Taraweeh is four prayers? I don't think you mean that, do you? The puzzle did not say that Salaam doesn't count, therefore four salaams in one prayer is applicable to the puzzle.

If Taraweeh is more than one prayer, it would have been called Salawaat-ut-Taraweeh, not Salaat-ut-Taraweeh. :)
Click to expand...

Salam

ooh I didn't think that part..:-/

um... Well maybe you're right. I mean... It's not like a one answer riddle, right? The funny thing is, when we handed in the riddles to the imam during ramadan trivia night, he never pointed out other possible answers (not that I'm saying nothing else counts)

Anyway. My explanation didn't work lol.

Someone else?

Salam.
 
IbnAdam77

IbnAdam77

Travelling towards my grave.
assalam 'alaikum warahmatullahi wabrakatuh

Sister Tabassum said it correctly for sure. Yeah and sister Summer (still I wonder why not Winter LOL - just kidding) said it correct too.

ayman1 said:
BTW, the above solution is not limited to Maghrib prayer, it will work for Zhuhr, `Asr and `Ishaa' as well.
Click to expand...

No brother I don't think so. Show me how does it?

wassalam 'alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh
 
ahmed_indian

ahmed_indian

to Allah we belong
Here is the answer:

Salah Maghrib when you join imam in 2nd rakat after ruku.

sisters kainath_girl, Tabassum07 and Summer03 got it right! seems brothers were sleeping. :lol:

you will sit with imam's 2nd rakat but it will not be counted. then u will sit in imam's 3rd rakat but it will be ur first. then again in ur own 2nd rakat and then 3rd rakaat after imam says tasleem. 1+1+1+1 = 4. :)

* how taraweeh??? :confused: :lol: did i not say its very common. btw, a salah ends with tasleem. *
 
ahmed_indian

ahmed_indian

to Allah we belong
Muslim_Gurl said:
You make four times Tashahhud when your not concentrating in prayer, and you make this mistake :p Im kidding :p
I don't know, I've never heard of this...
Click to expand...

your reason was truly funny sister. :D

ayman1 said:
Taraweeh prayer.
Click to expand...

it cant be bcoz its not commom and finished after 2 rakaats.:)

Tabassum07 said:
No way, I got it right too, is my answer invisible or something? :angryred: :angryblue: :tantrum1:
Click to expand...

no. ur answer was visible for all of us to see. :tongue: congrats! u got it right!

ayman1 said:
BTW, the above solution is not limited to Maghrib prayer, it will work for Zhuhr, `Asr and `Ishaa' as well.
Click to expand...

really? i think it is not possible!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top