Female Muslim/Islamic Scholars

Aapa

Mirajmom
Salaam,

To my sisters, forgive me. If I come across harsh it is simply because I do not want you to suffer. Think of me as an eccentric aunt who has had many many experiences and does not want you to have to have unnecessary pains.

In no means do I want to state I know best. I have made many, many mistakes. I want you to learn from my mistakes.

All I know, is Islam, is my home. It is the home of peace, It is the home of forgiveness. In returning to Islam from much foolishness and ignorance, I revere it.

You are the flowers of Islam. Think of me as a gardner protecting the beautiful plants.

To Brother GP: I will contact Ms. Ridley..had problems with e-mail address; will read everything you tell me..will respond once it sinks into this obtuse mind.

Olive oil is the best thing for dandruff.
 

omooba

New Member
asalama aleikum

jazakhallah khairun for all responding Phew...now i know i am not alone in my frustrations

i dont want easy fatwas or pushover imams i want practical guidance

for instance i know a lot of muslim women who work because one salary is not paying the bills, they may love their job but if their husbands suddenly had enough to support the family they would give up work but they realy need to work

however most times when the woman working is addressed we are encouraged not to work for a lot of people that is not a viable option
i know alot of women who earn more than their husbands and that money is givn up as sadaqah to help their husband pay the bills, they are obedient to him, they cook his food have his children and keep their homes, why is it never acknowledged instead they are told that their children are suffering and they are supposed to feel guilty

all i am asking for is a person who actually gets it, someone who understands and empathises and can give advice based on all womens experiences, so how to be a good muslimah, wife, mother and friend when there are 1001 responsibilities on you, something practical.

check the cds and tell me how many lectures are about the mans version of hijab, short trousers the beard they are a handful and the womens hijab thats the main concern of most people flip the script read the hadith and see how many are dedicated to the mens clothes compared to the women and then youll get it.

its hilarious a bunch of guys from my uni one day sitting in the cofee shop slating the muslim girls who dont wear hijab, guess what none of them have a beard, none of them wear their trousers the correct length. but they feel justified because now all the muslim woman has to do is wear the hijab and shes sorted.

we accept a lot trying to keep the peace and Masha Allah witht the full intention of pleasing Allah but speaking the truth in the face of a tyrant is the greatest jihad, dont get me wrong i am not saying the imamas are tyrants but what i am saying is if something is not right we should do something about it the sahabiat were strong women when Ummar RA tried to limit the dowry a woman can get a woman stood up in the crowd and defened her right and Ummar conceeded.

the womes liberation is a farce, islam gave us liberation but sometimes i feel like the muslims are slowly taking that liberation away and that is what makes me so frustarted.
 

amyaishazouaoui

Junior Member
:salam2:

Look, there are imams out there who you can speak to coherently and who will give you a very balanced view point, not all of them are sexist or one sided.


I think im finding my vocation in life (need to be a scholar.................................. let me finish course first!!!!!)

:wasalam:
 

Umm-Ahmed

New Member
Salaam,

Alhumdullilah.


As salaam 'alaykum wurahamatulaah wa barakatu

Forgive me this is only my second post on this forum, but as the topic is quite interesting to me I thought I could add to the discussion.

When we are asked to cover from head to toe from Allaah its for a good reason , lets start with modesty , maybe someone will say we dont need to be covered to be modest , we all know when we are covered we are away from prying eyes, and sisters that were not muslims before will recall speaking to boys at school or at uni that most were not always looking at our face when chatting to us. When your covered your respected for what you have to say.
Men are allowed to wear shorts although they should be very baggy and long down to the bottom of the knee , where as for us the whole of our bodies are awra to a man, because some men like feet some like knees , yes and some love womens hands , I am sure none of us sisters would like to be the reason a man was becoming aroused because he found a certain part of us attractive ( even though he should be lowering his gaze as commanded)


I live in a very hot climate, outside right now its about 105 F , if you buy the thicker abaya thats not transparent then you can wear a cotton dress underneath , wullaahi when I am out I dont feel the heat too much because I am layering my clothes , if your in the west dont wear these tight jilbabs that are restricting the movement of air around the arms and shoulders.
Its a lot hotter in a place where we could be put if we dont cover.

We are muslims striving against our desires night and day to have a life of ease in the hereafter , any tiny suffering even a pin prick you gain a reward , we see women swinging it down the high streets ,but she has given into her lusts and desires and she has no taqwa and we know where her abode is.

My dear sisters in Islaam when you read articles or hear lectures and they seem to be all on the topic of the hijaab its for a good reason , women are throwing off their hijaab daily , some women believe its an opression to be covered , the authors and daees receive mail and telephone calls from parents and husbands asking for help for their women folk who wont cover. The non muslims attack the hijaab constantly because it signifies our devotion to Allaah and his commands.

There are many speakers who talk about womens issues , like Muhammad Shareef and Jamal Zarabozo and Dr Bilal Phillips , and like was mentioned above the women asked our beloved phrophet (s.a.w) about the most intimate details and my sisters in Islaam the scholars when they study they go into the matters of women issues deeply , you dont have to bear a child to know that childbirth hurts or to know that the bond between a mother and her baby is something that a father wont feel , but a scholar knows that its that bond that gets the mother out of her bed 4 times during the night to feed and change her baby or to sit with a sick child all night.
Our scholars work hard for us they are in touch with scholars and ex students who have went back to their own countries , issues are explained to them regarding the east and west.

Finally I dont doubt that we do need women scholars and teachers we also need the male scholars and teachers who will do classes that adress the concerns of women privately.

May Allaah subhaanah wa taalaah guide us all on the path of moderation in all we do and say the sirat al mustaqeem

Umm Ahmed
 

ShyHijabi

Junior Member
Sister Omoobah,

Thank you so much for putting into words what I struggling to say. I am increasingly frustrated with what appears to be a double standard. At my school there is a huge focus on the girls who don't wear hijab and they are criticized at length. Whereas I don't criticize them but simply speak kindly and gently to them. Alhumdullilah a sister has just recently begun wearing hijab again after removing it last semester and I was one of the few that continued my friendship with her when she removed it. A lot of Muslims (even girls that did not wear hijab) stopped speaking to her. Now that she has put it back on she looks so much happier.

What I find so hypocritical is that no one seems to be inquiring about the brother who gave the hukbah and has his girlfriend living with him, he is very obvious about this. Or about the brother that attends Jummah on Friday and then goes out an gets drunk that night with his friends. Meanwhile these same brothers criticize the fact that my hijabs are pink or other such bright colors.

My need os for practical advice that I can apply to my everyday life. Islam is a religion of ease but it seems some folks want to try and make everything impossible.

Wasalaam.

~Sarah
 

aisha16

Junior Member
Assalam Allaykum sister Mirajmon asked me to post The Haram Police, the newest ummahfilms episode in this thread, so here it is.

[yt]b4Q1vHQxsss[/yt]
 

omooba

New Member
Masah Allah Tabarakallahu

thanks for the video little sis

i am guessing Sis Mirajmom asked for this to be put here so we'll all stop complaining

jazakallahu khayrun

point taken insha Allah.
 

omooba

New Member
Masah Allah Tabarakallahu

thanks for the video little sis

i am guessing Sis Mirajmom asked for this to be put here so we'll all stop complaining

jazakallahu khayrun sis mirajmom

point taken insha Allah.
 

Globalpeace

Banned
Way forward?

Asslamo Allaikum,

So we have had a great "Circular Argument"!

Whats the solution? Very interested to know what you Sisters are gonna do?

Because this is pivotal for your Islam?

I went for Hajj a few years ago & a woman Scholar gave a Fatwa that eating Orange during Ihraam was HARAM because Orange has fragrance and you can't have fragrance during Ihraam!

Got 200+ peoeple seriously worried and wound up!

So serious errors can be made by anyone. Hence my recommendation is to increase your knowledge & look at Fatwa and LEARN to analyse with some basic textual evidence checking i.e.

Ascertain the qualification & rank of Mufti; do you know the person?

Which Madhab is the Mufti following?

What the principles of Fatwa in that Madhab?

If he is not following a Madhab; he is still following some principles; what are they?

What is the position of his Fatwa in his own school or amongst his contemporaries (and past scholars)?

Someone gives you a verse of the Qur'aan; check Tafseer Ibn Khatheer Asha-Shafae (RA) or Tafseer Qurtubi (RA)?

Someone gives you a Hadeeth of Saheeh Bukhari; check Fathal Bari to see what Imam Ibnul Haj'r Al-Asqalani Ash-Shafi (RA) has to say about it?

Someone gives you a Hadeeth of Saheeh Muslim; check Shar'h of Saheeh Muslim to see what Imam Nawawi Ash-Shafi (RA) has to say about it?

so on & so forth

ASK the Scholars who have issued the Fatwa about the bits that you don't understand and they will be glad to clarify, Insha'Allah.

All of the above goes for men & women Scholars.

Lastly; does this FATWA represent Ijma (consensus of Muslim scholars), Jamhoor (majority opinion of scholars) or is it Shadh (rare)? Or is it ijtehaad ruling derived by a scholar when the answer is not clear cut in the Qur'aan/Sunnah.

P.S: I have really summarised bits; its a lengthy topic & I hope that Allah (SWT) grants me (first and foremost) and then all of my Sisters to embark on the road of beneficial knowledge and not to be abandon it till we die!

P.P.S: Read history and you will know HOW FATWAS & MUFTIS have been used & abused!

Example (during British Raj of India): One of the leading Muftees of India writes, "...Her Majesty the Queen of England is a benevolnece of Allah (SWT) upon the Muslim of India..."

This sect is still around Sisters and followed world-wide.
 

Oem Soufiane

Junior Member
assalamu aleikum wa rahmatulahi wa barakatuh

I didn't read all the posts, but i have to say, as a woman, i don't need female scholars, the reliable scholars we have like ibn baaz, Uthaimin etc. give answers according to the quran and sunnah.

I don't need an answer that fits me best, and if you are looking for a good 'female' book for three years and you haven't found a single one by now, then you have to ask yourself: do i adapt to islam, or does islam have to adapt to me? the correct answers to all our issues are already known in islam, and in whatever words they are pronounced, gentle or harsh, by a man or a woman, the answer is the same.
I really hate it when people are dividing. I saw another threat talking about black muslims and white muslims, WHAT ARE WE DOING??? we are muslims, since when does color or gender matter? :astag:
 

Aapa

Mirajmom
Salaam sister,

By constantly dividing us we become weak.. when you live in racist societies..you become accustomed to recognizing the color of your skin.
You are absolutely correct the color of your skin is a physical dimension of our existence...yet to rule..our physical apperance is one of the markers..

i didn't make this crazy world up...it makes little sense..but it is here. there are always divisions in every society.they perpetuate a need..as long as we are needy or a state of want ( not being what we are prescribed to be ) we will be weak.

it is the object of nonbelivers to make Muslim women feel we are needy..it is a very simple way of making our ummah weak...we are led to believe we are held in bondage by barbarians...and every so often they will take a sister and flaunt her for a moment in front of the camera until she becomes boring and they move on to the next woman who will sell her soul to please the non-belivers.

You are correct.we have instruction and guidance. We are told to be patient. We are told that whatever befalls us is a trial..I think of our sisters in Palestine and Iraq..I know on the Day of Judgement their beauty will radiate...
 

q8penpals

Junior Member
assalamu aleikum wa rahmatulahi wa barakatuh

I didn't read all the posts, but i have to say, as a woman, i don't need female scholars, the reliable scholars we have like ibn baaz, Uthaimin etc. give answers according to the quran and sunnah.

I don't need an answer that fits me best, and if you are looking for a good 'female' book for three years and you haven't found a single one by now, then you have to ask yourself: do i adapt to islam, or does islam have to adapt to me? the correct answers to all our issues are already known in islam, and in whatever words they are pronounced, gentle or harsh, by a man or a woman, the answer is the same.
I really hate it when people are dividing. I saw another threat talking about black muslims and white muslims, WHAT ARE WE DOING??? we are muslims, since when does color or gender matter? :astag:


Assalam Aliekum

Wow, I didn't realize my simple question about notable female Islamic Scholars would turn into such a debate. I never meant that I wanted some "Feminist" scholar, just a reputable, educated female scholar. Goodness knows there are plenty of wacky "scholars" out there (male and female).

I will say that I find it difficult for some of the hardcore scholars to relate to the special needs/problems of converts - dealing with non-Muslim family celebrations for example. I posted a question once on a pretty reputable website (the name escapes me now), and was basically told (I am paraphrasing), that if I participated in the kafir activities I would be going to hell. So I asked another question about disobeying my parents or disowning family, and was told again that I was going to hell if I did that. Now, I AM NOT SAYING THAT IS TRUE OR A FATWA OR ANYTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I am simply saying, it is hard to know who to listen to.

And, I still believe, no man can truly understand all the problems that women of today face. LIke the sister who posted about Muslimahs that NEED to work to help keep their family alive - many "scholars" simply say it is the man's job to provide and the woman shouldn't work.

Yeah, that doesn't always work, people. And what about the woman's emotions in this case? Maybe she WANTS to be a housewife, at home, and she is practically forced to hold a job because she wants to feed and clothe her children and her husband's salary doesn't cut it? So she is working a job that she may hate, may feel bad feelings to her husband (or even God!) that she is being made to choose between staying at home with her children, or actually feeding them?j

A female scholar does not need to be a "feminist" in order to counsel women in correct Islamic fashion. I know many women (and we all know that this is almost a global epidemic) who have been beaten and opressed by fathers, husbands, even their brothers, who have no trust in men, and therefore would not go to a man for advice in marriage or relationships - so who is supposed to help her?

Many of us have also probably met the Imam at the mosque who, when asked about a marital problem, blame some shortcoming of the woman and the one and only cause for the problem - not the fact that that particular man may just be an abusive jerk no matter what his wife does for him.

I am sorry my post turned into a whole debate about hijab and everything, I just wanted to be able to find out who some reputable female scholars (not feminists) were.

Lana
 

ShyHijabi

Junior Member
Salaam Sister Lana,

Your argument is sound and brings up some very valid points. As a convert who has been disowned by her family you touched on a lot of points I am still struggling with. I am told we need male escorts when leaving the house but I do not access to one. When I inquire as to what I am supposed to do, I meet silence or get a repsonse that basically ignores the crux of my question.

I have no famliy to care for me or help me economically so I must find a way to make it on my own. I have no wali and might be looking at marriage in my future and have been floundering about what to do.

Islam is beautiful and perfect, the followers...not so much. I am praised and encouraged by the parents of my friends when they find I am a convert. These same parents refuse to allow their children to marry someone from a different race, nationality or even tribe. This is hypocrisy.

I think scholars can be good or bad...be they male or female. But I do think we need someone who understands what it means to be a woman in today's society, particularly with the challenges of being a female convert. Our struggles are unique and from my personal experience, seem to be ignored by the majority of the Ummah. This is personal experience only so I may be completely wrong about the overall climate of the Ummah.

Wasalaam

~Sarah
 

Oem Soufiane

Junior Member
I am a female convert too, still didn't change my mind, I know it is difficult at most times, however we will be rewarded for everything we struggle with inshallah. :blackhijab: and I wasn't attacking anyone just shared my point of view sisters.:hijabi:
 
Top