it looks like my language was still confusing people. The reciter in the video is Sa'ad al Ghamidi and he is not at all controvercial. The controvercial person, about whom some brothers were talking about is not brother Sa'ad al Ghamidi but Javed Ahmed Ghamidi. And if you take my personal opinion, which is contrast with some brothers in the forum, Javed Ahmed Ghamidi never leaves the bounds of Quran and Sunnah, so he is not controvercial to me.