nice story...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Summer03

3doTs2sQuares

There was once a man who was an enemy to Islam. He had three famous questions that no person could answer. No Islamic scholar in Baghdad could answer his three questions...thus he made fun of Islam in public. He constantly ridiculed Islam and the Muslims. One day a small boy, who`s age was 10, came along and heard the man yelling and screaming at Muslims in the street. He was challenging people openly to answer the three questions.

The boy stood quietly and watched. He then decided that he would challenge the man. He walked up and told the man, "I will accept your challenge".

The man laughed at the boy and ridiculed the Muslims even more by saying, "A ten year old boy challenges me. Is this all you people have to offer!"

But the boy patiently reiterated his stance. He would challenge the man, and with Allah`s help and guidance, he would put this to an end. The man finally accepted.

The entire city gathered around a small "hill" where open addresses were usually made. The man climbed to the top, and in a loud voice asked his first question.

"What is your God doing right now?"

The small boy thought for a little while and then told the man to climb down the hill and to allow him to go up in order to address the question.

The man says "What? You want me to come down?"

The boy says, "Yes. I need to reply, right?"

The man made his way down and the small boy, age 10, with his little feet made his way up.

This small child`s reply was "Oh Allah Almighty! You be my witness in front of all these people. You have just willed that a Kafir be brought down to a low level, and that a Muslim be brought to a high level!"

The crowd cheered and screamed "Takbir"...."Allah-hu-akbar!!!"

The man was humiliated, but he boldly asked his Second question... "What existed before your God?"

The small child thought and thought.

Then he asked the man to count backwards. "Count from 10 backwards."

The man counted..."10, 9 ,8 , 7 , 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1,0"

The boy asked, "What comes before 0 ?"

The man: "I don`t know...nothing."

The boy: "Exactly. Nothing was before Allah, for He is eternal and absolute."

The crowd cheered again...."Takbir!"...."Allah-hu-akbar!!!!"

The man, now completely frustrated, asked his final question. "In which direction is your Allah facing?"

The boy thought and thought.

He then asked for a candle. A candle was brought to him. The blessed child handed it to the man and asked him to light it.

The man did so and remarked, "What is this supposed to prove?"

The young boy asked, "In which direction is light from the candle going?"

The man responded, "It is going in all directions."

The boy: "You have answered your own question. Allah`s light (noor) goes in all directions. He is everywhere. There is no where that He cannot be found.

"The crowd cheered again...."Takbir!"...."Allah-hu-akbar!!!"

The man was so impressed and so moved by the boy`s knowledge and spirituality, that he embraced Islam and became a student of the young boy.

So ended the debate.

Who was the young boy?

The young boy was one of our leaders and one of the greatest scholars, Imam Abu Hanîfa (May Allah bless him).
 

warda A

Sister
subhannallah

:salam2:


:ma:

subhannallah
That was quite inspiring and quite a boost to the youth.

do you have any evidence that it was indeed Imam Abu Hanifa?
:ma:
:tti_sister:
 

Al-Kashmiri

Well-Known Member
Staff member
As-salaamu `alaykum warahmatullaah.

Since this topic is about Al-Imaam, Abu Haneefah Nu`maan Ibn Thaabit, rahimahullaah, I will begin by quoting from one of those who studied with him, `Abdullaah Ibn Mubaarak, rahimahullaah,

"The isnaad (chain of narration) is part of the religion and had it not been for the isnaad, whoever wished would have said whatever he liked"
[Saheeh Muslim; Introduction]

So please, before posting bring references so that one can be sure that it isn't totally fabricated. As for the actual discussion then I have seen very similar stories of a similar nature, regarding Abu Haneefah, him refuting some heretics and him being a child at the time.

Some of them I have seen involve `Ilm ul-Kalaam (haraam rhetoric which is rejected by Ahl us-Sunnah), and discussions that contradict what the salaf have narrated about the names and attributes of Allaah, subhaanahu wata`aala. The most authentic and widespread book on the `Aqeedah of Imaam Abu Haneefah and his students, Abu Yusuf and Abu `Abdullaah (Ash-Shaybaanee), is Imaam At-Tahaawee's Al-`Aqeedatut-Tahaawiyyah. The 77th point of this work states that Allaah is not contained by the 6 directions contrary to the creation, meaning none of the creation can encompass Him (to further elloborate the 119th point states that he is above all). This is what Abu Haneefah and his students believed, yet the above contradicts it (regarding the candle). In addition, the Imaam, Abu Haneefah would never liken Allaah (tashbeeh) to his creation; a candle?!

We wish not to dispute about these points but as I said these so-called stories often contain ambiguities that contradict the sunnah, hence we do not wish to see them on this site.

For more information about the Asmaa' and Sifaat of Allaah, see the following threads/posts,
http://www.turntoislam.com/forum/showthread.php?t=104
http://www.turntoislam.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10961&postcount=3


Closed...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top