Asja
Pearl of Islaam
You can see the perfect example by the death of first born in Prophet Mouses (pbuh)'s ten plague. What have they done to Prophet Mouses (pbuh)? Nothing. But are their parents are all innocent? Well, you can't know exactly because there are not detail explanations. It is related to your question about their parents. Have you done complete background check so you know that they are all not involved in muslim children killings? They can be involved somehow by donating, supporting, etc. Sometimes Allah's way to repay is vary and not directly, but it will do hurt the oppressor. You can see how pharaoh and usa devastated by this.
Assalamu allaicum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuhu
Dear sister you can not take one example and apply it in all situacions. This what you are saying and those Muslims who hold the same opinion like your yourself is wrong. May Allah guide you. Ameen.
This has nothing to do with Islaam neither with Islamic teaching Alhamdulilah, niether something like this is allowed by Allah or mentioned and approved by our Prophet sallahu alayha wa saalam. Nobody can carry the burden of sin of anyone and eveyone will be held accountable only for his deeds Especailly it is wrong to think and even to affirm that something like this is allowed in Islaam.
Islam is teaching us a compassion and justice toward others. Every life is valuable by itself Alhadmulillah, every breath is valuable, and our religion is teaching us that whoever be a couse that one life be saved, it is like he has saved all humanity.
Even if these parents have fault for some crimes against Muslims, their innocnet children like any other innocent child is not blameworthy for anything and Alhamdulillah they all also deserve to live and have a future like all other children. Allah is a Just Alhamdulillah,and He does not punish unjusticly, especially not to punish someone trough thier children Astagfirullah.
Who would dare call her a fake musilm? who would dare tell her how can she rejoice and pray for the death of children? Have they felt her pain? have they walked a mile in her shoes? it's easy to judge others from the comforts of our home, free from such hardship. It's easy to take the higher "moral" ground and label others. The world is not black and white.
I don't think there is any point of discussing this any further, we have two sides with two opposing view points. You won't changes yours and you can't change the others. Everyone is entitled to their views so let's just leave it at.
Assalamu allaicum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuhu
Dear sister, nobody would call other Muslim as not real Muslim one the base of his/ her feelings which can be coused by anger, pain, or despair of loosing one child, neither it is allowed by Islaam to judge other Muslims without proves abour themselves. But having personal feelings about something it has nothing to do with a fact that something like this, wishing a death to innocent children, or even thinking that Allah will accept this kind of dua it is wrong Alhamdulillah.
May Allah guide us all. Ameen summa ameen
:salam2: