Sh. Muhammad Hassan Walid Didou Al-Shinqiti- On Shaykh al-Albaani

Status
Not open for further replies.
virtualeye

virtualeye

Tamed Brother
Globalpeace said:
Asslamo Allaikum,

Stop; putting the picture of woman on your post...

You are confusing me.

:SMILY335: :SMILY335: :SMILY335:
Click to expand...

WaAlaikumussalaam,


If you see carefully then it is actually a brother in a shawl.

If it is sister then does it mean only sisters can say MashaAllah in icon? Also ":astag: " is only for brothers. :D


Wassalaam
VE
 
Globalpeace

Globalpeace

Banned
Brother in a Shawl!

W-Salam,

Stop talking about Pathans in that way!

I might get upset

:astag:

virtualeye said:
WaAlaikumussalaam,


If you see carefully then it is actually a brother in a shawl.

If it is sister then does it mean only sisters can say MashaAllah in icon? Also ":astag: " is only for brothers. :D


Wassalaam
VE
Click to expand...
 
I

Imad

Junior Member
Assalmoelaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh,

What i want to say is : " the Ashairah are not from ahlu suna-waljama3a" That's the reason why i have put the link. Alhamdullilah you agree with the information which the link provides.

When i finished the Ghothba about the attributes of Allah and prayed Salaat el Jumu3a an Asharie came to me. He said i want to give you an advice, what you said about Allah is not true, what you said is shirk" . Subhanallah i gave him clear evidences, but he denied. I said Allah is above the heavens.

He denied.

When i wanted to shake with him hands he didn't want to shake with me hands. I said "do you think i'am a mushrik, he said: " I don't know".

They use "El3aql" Qabla Naql. They use their "Logic" before Naql ( evidence). They use Philosophy , they use ilm elkalaam.

I gave Him many evidences which are sahieh, but he denied.

Also i have talked with him about el Albanie, bin baaz, el Utheimien and Ibn Taymia. What do you think he said: " They are followers of the devil"

My dear brother i love you for the sake of Allah, because i saw you are a deffender of the right aqeeda, but i want to give you advice to read from big-scholars what they have said about el ashairah. So My dear brother don't copy and paste before you read the whole article.

Wassalmoelaikoem warahamatullahi wbarakatuh
 
Globalpeace

Globalpeace

Banned
To edit or not to edit!

W-Salam,

I read the article & also read the bottom of the message; but didn't want to cut it out because that would have been wrong & not delivering the whole message accurately.

I had to debate with myself for sometime about this...

I liked the way how the Shaykh has defended Shaykh Al-Albani (RA), Masha'Allah.

The message is about ignoring blind following & accepting that scholars no matter how good can make errors.

Did the Brother actually said those words? I am sorry but that's wrong and uncalled for!

Imad said:
Assalmoelaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh,

What i want to say is : " the Ashairah are not from ahlu suna-waljama3a" That's the reason why i have put the link. Alhamdullilah you agree with the information which the link provides.

When i finished the Ghothba about the attributes of Allah and prayed Salaat el Jumu3a an Asharie came to me. He said i want to give you an advice, what you said about Allah is not true, what you said is shirk" . Subhanallah i gave him clear evidences, but he denied. I said Allah is above the heavens.

He denied.

When i wanted to shake with him hands he didn't want to shake with me hands. I said "do you think i'am a mushrik, he said: " I don't know".

They use "El3aql" Qabla Naql. They use their "Logic" before Naql ( evidence). They use Philosophy , they use ilm elkalaam.

I gave Him many evidences which are sahieh, but he denied.

Also i have talked with him about el Albanie, bin baaz, el Utheimien and Ibn Taymia. What do you think he said: " They are followers of the devil"

My dear brother i love you for the sake of Allah, because i saw you are a deffender of the right aqeeda, but i want to give you advice to read from big-scholars what they have said about el ashairah. So My dear brother don't copy and paste before you read the whole article.

Wassalmoelaikoem warahamatullahi wbarakatuh
Click to expand...
 
I

Imad

Junior Member
Assalmo alaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh,

Jazakallahu gairan brother for your reply.

Many Scholars have written about Al-albany and they have praised him for his great work. The big problem with the article you have posted is:
" The author is deffending el Asha3irah "

I'am sorry if you read the whole article, but why posting this article if you saw the deffending of El asha3irah. There are more articles of scholars which are talking about blind following.

Think about what Imam Malik, Imam Ashafi3ie, Imam Aboe Hanifa. Imam ahmad ibn Hanbal. and Imam el Albany is one of the persons who has collected their sayings ( If i am not wrong) about not following them blindly.

You have to know el Asha3irah are people of ilm el Kalaam, they deny some attributes of Allah.

Ibn baaz Rahimahu llah said:


ومن العقائد المضادة للعقيدة الصحيحة في باب الأسماء والصفات عقائد أهل البدع من الجهمية والمعتزلة ومن سلك سبيلهم في نفي صفات الله عز وجل وتعطيله سبحانه من صفات الكمال ووصفه عز وجل بصفة المعدومات والجمادات والمستحيلات، تعالى الله عن قولهم علوا كبيرا.

ويدخل في ذلك من نفي بعض الصفات وأثبت بعضها كالأشاعرة فإنه يلزمهم فيما أثبتوه من الصفات نظير ما فروا منه في الصفات التي نفوها وتأولوا أدلتها فخالفوا بذلك الأدلة السمعية والعقلية، وتناقضوا في ذلك تناقضا بينا.

I think you can read and understand arabic. If you want me to help you with translation, insha Allah i will help you. But my engelish is not very well.

Take care my brother.

Wassalmoelaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh
 
alkathiri

alkathiri

As-Shafaa'i(Brother)
Imad said:
Assalmo alaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh,

Jazakallahu gairan brother for your reply.

Many Scholars have written about Al-albany and they have praised him for his great work. The big problem with the article you have posted is:
" The author is deffending el Asha3irah "

I'am sorry if you read the whole article, but why posting this article if you saw the deffending of El asha3irah. There are more articles of scholars which are talking about blind following.

Think about what Imam Malik, Imam Ashafi3ie, Imam Aboe Hanifa. Imam ahmad ibn Hanbal. and Imam el Albany is one of the persons who has collected their sayings ( If i am not wrong) about not following them blindly.

You have to know el Asha3irah are people of ilm el Kalaam, they deny some attributes of Allah.

Ibn baaz Rahimahu llah said:


ومن العقائد المضادة للعقيدة الصحيحة في باب الأسماء والصفات عقائد أهل البدع من الجهمية والمعتزلة ومن سلك سبيلهم في نفي صفات الله عز وجل وتعطيله سبحانه من صفات الكمال ووصفه عز وجل بصفة المعدومات والجمادات والمستحيلات، تعالى الله عن قولهم علوا كبيرا.

ويدخل في ذلك من نفي بعض الصفات وأثبت بعضها كالأشاعرة فإنه يلزمهم فيما أثبتوه من الصفات نظير ما فروا منه في الصفات التي نفوها وتأولوا أدلتها فخالفوا بذلك الأدلة السمعية والعقلية، وتناقضوا في ذلك تناقضا بينا.

I think you can read and understand arabic. If you want me to help you with translation, insha Allah i will help you. But my engelish is not very well.

Take care my brother.

Wassalmoelaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh
Click to expand...

:salam2:
well brother, if Say imam Shafii can go wrong in some of his teachings ... so can ibn baaz and Albanii...Some shaykh take literal meanings frm the quran.. is that correct??
 
I

Imad

Junior Member
Assalmoalaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh,

My dear brother i don't understand your point. Do you think i said Ibn Baaz and el Albany Rahimahumullah are infallible?

Some shaykh take literal meanings frm the quran.. is that correct??
Click to expand...

My dear brother i don't understand your point in the Quote. please I want more clarity to give an answer to your Question.

Thank you brother for your reply.

Take care

Wassalmoealaikoem warahmatullahi wbarakatuh
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top