About the thread "Killing apostates"

[ayman]

:salam2:
this thread has been deleted for many reasons:
We are not here to talk about such subjects, this site is about islam and about misconceptions about islam, and many of the members are talking like if they were scholars " if ..... then ....., but if ..... then lets do this or that ",
astagfirullah, fear Allah, fear Allah , fear Allah, stop giving own fatwas like if u were talking about a footbal match, we have scholars alhamdulillah who we can ask, dont we ??? Who are the True Scholars from Whom Knowledge is Taken?


and here is an other reminder for me and for everyone inchAllah :


Do not give ur own fatwaa

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

assalamu alaikum wrwb

i wanted to ask other members of this forum to please stop giving their own fatwaas.

u can ofcourse share a fatwa of some learned scholar or mufti but do not pass on anything which u think is correct without any proper proof. so be sure and mindful that whatever u share on this site is backed by a scholarly opinion, i really like the articles of other members who post the rulings of scholars from islamqa or the fatwas of great sheikhs like ibn taymiyyah , ibn al qayyim, ibn baaz or ibn uthaymeen and so on.

even the hadees which look straightforward have a great inner meaning and needs a lot of knowledge of the quran and the deen to be interpreted. that is the reason why many of our greatest scholars have dedicated their entire lives and only then have become good muhaddiseen.

iam writing all this not to hurt anyone here but i have seen some ppl who have written some replies or answers and have made things haraam which are otherwise halaal and viceversa. and they have done this without any proof.

there are a lot of members/guests on this site who are either new muslims or young muslims and also a few who have limited knowledge of the deen (like me) who tend to take everything which they read on this forum to be correct. so its our duty to share and educate others with the most correct and authentic knowledge of the deen.

my dear members this is a very serious matter and i hope everyone understands what my point is in posting this.

i think everyone is free to give their own opinions if someone asks for a advice but not on scholarly issues.

And please refrain from posting any fatwas or rulings without authentic backing.

Thankyou all for reading this.
assalamu alaikum wrwb
by brother tombstone

 

[samiha]

:salam2:

Jazakallahu khayran brother!

I was going to think along the very same lines, thanks for getting to it first.

wasalam

 

[halah]

:salam2:
this thread has been deleted for many reasons:
We are not here to talk about such subjects, this site is about islam and about misconceptions about islam, and many of the members are talking like if they were scholars " if ..... then ....., but if ..... then lets do this or that ",
astagfirullah, fear Allah, fear Allah , fear Allah, stop giving own fatwas like if u were talking about a footbal match, we have scholars alhamdulillah who we can ask, dont we ??? Who are the True Scholars from Whom Knowledge is Taken?


and here is an other reminder for me and for everyone inchAllah :


Do not give ur own fatwaa

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

assalamu alaikum wrwb

i wanted to ask other members of this forum to please stop giving their own fatwaas.

u can ofcourse share a fatwa of some learned scholar or mufti but do not pass on anything which u think is correct without any proper proof. so be sure and mindful that whatever u share on this site is backed by a scholarly opinion, i really like the articles of other members who post the rulings of scholars from islamqa or the fatwas of great sheikhs like ibn taymiyyah , ibn al qayyim, ibn baaz or ibn uthaymeen and so on.

even the hadees which look straightforward have a great inner meaning and needs a lot of knowledge of the quran and the deen to be interpreted. that is the reason why many of our greatest scholars have dedicated their entire lives and only then have become good muhaddiseen.

iam writing all this not to hurt anyone here but i have seen some ppl who have written some replies or answers and have made things haraam which are otherwise halaal and viceversa. and they have done this without any proof.

there are a lot of members/guests on this site who are either new muslims or young muslims and also a few who have limited knowledge of the deen (like me) who tend to take everything which they read on this forum to be correct. so its our duty to share and educate others with the most correct and authentic knowledge of the deen.

my dear members this is a very serious matter and i hope everyone understands what my point is in posting this.

i think everyone is free to give their own opinions if someone asks for a advice but not on scholarly issues.

And please refrain from posting any fatwas or rulings without authentic backing.

Thankyou all for reading this.
assalamu alaikum wrwb
by brother tombstone

:salam2::ma:jazaka Allah khair ,I totaly agree with you.

 

[alkathiri]

:salam2:

JazakAllah khair. It has ben a long time since i saw you post in the TTI english forum....

Actually for me, i am also against people posting hadith to prove their points even if they turn out to be correct. I believe that is the job of scholars and student of knowledge ,the least. How many of us are actually learning under scholars every day. I doubt there is anyone here.

If you want to post hadith , make sure it has commentary by any of the 4 imams or classical scholars or great scholars of our time. If not i will just ignore what is posted . Look here, even Sheikh Salih Almunajid use commentay by the 4 imams and others. This message also goes out to admin and super moderators

So the best is to get answers from islamqa, and other well known islamic sites

 

[abou haytam]

salam o alikom

jazak allah khayran. i hope this thread will not disapear and the member read it.

allaho almostaan.