Raping slave women in Islam is Okay?

al-muslimah

Junior Member
:salam2:

This is quoted from a person I know who is currently searching for the truth and reading the Quran. He went through 70% of reading and loving it. He just wants to make sure all his questions are answered. So here is a question he posted and I don't have enough information to reply back. Would you kindly help?

I am somewhat bothered about the fact that the Qur'an constantly justifies sex with slave women. I have also read that Muhammad and many of his followers would make slaves out of the women who's husbands the Muslims just killed. Seems like rape to me. Is there something that I do not understand here? I understand that Islam greatly advanced the rights of women and slaves, but it still seems wrong to capture women and then rape them.

Jazakum Allahu Khayran in advance.

:wasalam:
 
:salam2: This guy who is asking this question is coming from answering-christianity.com This is a question put by them trying to prove islam wrong but they are the mistaken ones. This is a islam hate group.
 
:salam2:
When Islam was reveled to Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him), slavery was a worldwide common social phenomenon; it was much older than Islam. Slavery was deeply rooted in every society to the extent that it was impossible to imagine a civilized society without slaves.

In spite of this social fact, Islam was the first religion to recognize slavery as a social illness that needed to be addressed. Since slavery was deeply rooted in the society, Islam did not abolish it at once. Rather, Islam treated slavery in the same manner it treated other social illnesses. Islam followed the same methodology of gradual elimination in dealing with this social disease as it did with other social illnesses, for example: the prohibition of alcohol in three steps.

Concerning having slave women, we would like to let you know that it happens to be a practice necessitated by the condition in which early Muslims found themselves vis-a-vis non-Muslims, as both parties engaged in wars. Slave women or milk al-yameen are referred to in the Qur'an as “Those whom your right hand possess” or “ma malakat aymanukum”; they are those taken as captives during conquests and subsequently became slaves, or those who were descendants of slaves.

Thus, it was a war custom in the past to take men and women as captives and then turn them into slaves. Islam did not initiate it, rather, it was something in practice long ago before the advent of Islam. And when Islam came, it tried to eradicate this practice, bit by bit. So it first restricted it to the reciprocal practice of war, in the sense that Muslims took war captives just as the enemies did with Muslims.

But as it aimed at putting an end to such issue, Islam laid down rules which would eventually lead to eradicating the practice. So it allowed Muslims to have intercourse with slave women taken as captives of just and legitimate wars. In so doing, the woman would automatically become free if she got pregnant. What's more, her child would also become free.

Not only that, Islam also ordered a Muslim to treat the slave woman in every respect as if she were his wife. She should be well fed, clothed and given due protection. In the family environment, she had the opportunity to learn about Islam and was free to accept it or reject it. She also had the opportunity to earn her freedom for she could be ransomed.

In the light of the above-mentioned facts, and the nature of the question posed by people, it's clear that some people misunderstand the wisdom behind the permissibility of having female slaves and think that it is meant to unleash men’s desires and give them more enjoyment. Never! That is not the point! It is, rather, means of freeing slaves; and this is clarified above in the fact that if a master got a female slave pregnant, then he could neither sell her nor give her away as a present. And if he died, she would not be considered part of his property. She'd receive her freedom and her baby would also be free.

But, we have to stress that this case should not be confused with that of female servants or maids, for they are free and not slaves. Therefore, it is forbidden to engage in sexual relations with them except through an Islamic marriage.

Slavery has been abolished by international conventions, and goes in line with aims and objectives of Islam, as it has called for centuries ago.

As for marrying slaves, it is something permissible under two conditions: first, if one is unable to pay the dowry of a free woman. Second, if there is fear of committing adultery if one doesn’t get married. This is clarified by the following verse: “And whose is not able to afford to marry free, believing women, let them marry from the believing maids whom your right hands possess. This is for him among you who feareth to commit sin. But to have patience would be better for you.” (An-Nisaa’: 25)

This verse shows that Muslim men should abstain from illicit relations and seek enjoyment through marriage to free women or through their female slaves.

In conclusion, Allah has forbidden certain types of behavior and permitted other kinds of behavior as a safeguard to the individual and to the society. Allah has forbidden fornication and adultery. However, in the case of captives whom your right hands posses, it's something necessitated by the special circumstances which were created when the Muslims were at war.”
 

Searching_soul

Junior Member
:salam2:

Truly Amazing answer sister :)
I don't think anyone could have said it any better.....
May ALLAH (swt) reward you for this.... ameen

:wasalam:
 

ahmed_indian

to Allah we belong
:salam2: This guy who is asking this question is coming from answering-christianity.com This is a question put by them trying to prove islam wrong but they are the mistaken ones. This is a islam hate group.

no sister. its a wonderful site to show the truth of Islam. it is run by Osama Abdullah, a palestinian.

i know, u meant another site. but lets not name it here. let it not make it popular. :silence:
 

naz haider

Junior Member
Wonderful reply sister. :ma:
I did not know about this and it was an eye opener to read the 'article'. The more I learn about Islam... the more I love it.
Allahu Akbar.... May Allah bless you for your good deeds sis....
:salam2:
 

a_stranger

Junior Member
:salam2:

:ma: very intersting argument , I like to add that Allah sobhanahu wa taala knows needs of humans and respond to them in a desent pure manner : those slave girls has the right to have family and children : this mulk alyameen is a legal contract like marriage which respect the rights of both sides .......still Islam didn`t support slavery ...it was rooted in societies before Islam ...so Islam dealt with it with wisdom and called to free slaves gradually ...it was unwise to free them one step since many of them were totally dependent on their masters ...you can`t put the diable in the street without enough training ....Islam started with freeing souls from shirk, selfishness , greed, lusts, anger, hate, ................many black locks that chain humanity then make freeing a slave a very good deed which free man from hell:It is) to free a slave,

Did We not assign unto him two eyes (8) And a tongue and two lips, (9) And guide him to the parting of the mountain ways? (10) But he hath not attempted the Ascent - (11) Ah, what will convey unto thee what the Ascent is! - (12) (It is) to free a slave, (13) And to feed in the day of hunger. (14) An orphan near of kin, (15) Or some poor wretch in misery, (16) And to be of those who believe and exhort one another to perseverance and exhort one another to pity. (17) Their place will be on the right hand. (18) But those who disbelieve Our revelations, their place will be on the left hand. (19) Fire will be an awning over them. (20)

Translation of the meanings of Quran
 

al-muslimah

Junior Member
sister basic of islam..may allah grant you jannatul firdaws. You did a great job.You speak wise mashallah..

Jazakallah khayran for all who spent time here replying back. I reallyyyy appreciate it!!

oh thankyou also sister a_stranger but there is somthing i didnt understand
many black locks that chain humanity then make freeing a slave a very good deed which free man from hell
am i missing somthing here? miss spelt? umm please clearify..the verses just fit..i loved them
 

a_stranger

Junior Member
:salam2:
<<oh thankyou also sister a_stranger but there is somthing i didnt understand

Quote:
many black locks that chain humanity then make freeing a slave a very good deed which free man from hell >>

Sorry sister for my poor English , what I meant is that the main issue in Islam is to free humans .....there are many unseen chains which lock human hearts and block them ...so Islam start by freeing souls from all kinds of evil ....then free slaves from slavery ..........Islam makes the reward of puiryfing hearts and freeing a slave freedom from Hell. I hope i made myself more clear
 

al-muslimah

Junior Member
I sent him the answer and I got the reply.

So having sex with slave women was generally meant for procreative purposes?

Thank you for this information.

Can someone help with the answer please?
 

Abu Talib

Feeling low
I sent him the answer and I got the reply.



Can someone help with the answer please?

I think you should really understand is he really trying to know or just trying to ask you more question which would make you think and end up being confused.

For the question he asked you should ask him first why does he have sex? For fun, natural tendency or for children?

I think that the question is precisely intended to divulge our thinking.
 

al-muslimah

Junior Member
well brother..he is trying to search for the truth..inshallah for real..i noticed this through his posts and words. I sent him Basicofislam's answer and some of the other sis/bro's points. He liked the given info but then he asks another question that i don't understand. I need help please. thankyou
 
Top