Discussion in 'Islamic Discussion' started by ixplora, Feb 24, 2010.
Does anyone know what this is on top of AL Masjad Al Nabawi? (Medina)
Wow I never knew this.. I amused by this catch..
Hope some one knows about this..
It says in the Arab text that someone is buried up there, but that is obviously a Lie. We just need confirmation from someone to tell us what it actually is?
That sounds bizarre how can anyone be buried there. ALLAHU ALAM
May be someone experienced would know. I have seen this first time in my life, hope its not morphed.
No one is buried there of course its just a lie but that place does exist the picture is not photoshopped or morphed in anyway, here you can see the picture from a different angle and that place there also.
Well I shouldn't be bothered that much about it except I just need to know what it is it. As per my knowledge that dome also should not exist based on fatwas by Shiekh Bin Baaz Rahimullah and Shiekh Salih ibn uthaymeen.
Ever the Dome was build on the Prophet's (may Allah peace and Blessing be upon him), righteous scholars have denounced it (in the light of Quran and Sunnah), the dome did not exists in the days of for Caliphs, nor in the the Tabiabeen, it was build after 500+, you can - please refer to the site islamqa_com/en (replace _ with .)
islamqa_com/en/ref/110061 (replace _ with .)
you can easily find other fatwas against the the green dome were easily if search and ask about
No one still seems to know what that bit is on the dome? The nearest possible answer is that it may be a maintenance door to the roof?
that seems like it^^
Yep. I am still wondering what would it be. Seems like gotta ask some person old person from Medina or an islamic historian
:salam2: i see this first time what is that cam anyone tell us
Someone on another forum suggested it maybe something to neutralise thunderstrikes? like a lightning conductor but that has not been confirmed.
wooooo! ieven im seeing it first time.
Still no information as to what that is?
I cannot see your picture so i cannot be 100% sure!
but if this is the green dome above the prophet mosque
then it's above the prophet peace be upon him grave
Why can't you see the picture? here it is again for you
i can see this pic
and yes this is the prophet peace be upon him green dome
his grave is beneath it
what a useless thread.
so whatever it is, does it even matter?
i can understand why somebody might be confused but before asking anything we must ascertain whether that knowledge will be beneficial or not.
and let's not speculate anything. there are saudi citizens on this forum, let them answer if they know.
even if we come to know what it is, it will not benefit us anyway. and even after that people will continue to speculate!
It does matter as unnecessary lies and conspiracy theories are being spread around regarding this, once cleared up it will silence those involved spreading such things, ignoring it will only mean it will carry on.
lets hope that some of the saudi members can clear this up
I have put this question across 4 different forums and no one seems to have a clue about what that could be?
Separate names with a comma.