distrubing question
- Thread starter saima abdullah
- Start date
ahmed_indian
to Allah we belong
jazaak Allah khair a lot brother. i hear this dua in friday khutbahs but never able to understand it.
ahmed_indian
to Allah we belong
brother AbuBaseer is giving the info about wrong practices and deviated sects. whts wrong with that?
we term right path as fanaticism and extremism and blame americans and non-muslims for that! SubhanAllah...truly strange!
Hard Rock Moslem
I'm your brother
JazakhAllah khairan akhi.
BinteShafi
Left long ago
:salam2:
O Allaah, Lord of Jibraa’eel, Meekaa’eel and Israafeel (great angels), Creator of the heavens and the Earth, Knower of the seen and the unseen. You are the arbitrator between Your servants in that which they have disputed. Guide me to the truth by Your leave, in that which they have differed, for verily You guide whom You will to a straight path.’
O Allaah, Lord of Jibraa’eel, Meekaa’eel and Israafeel (great angels), Creator of the heavens and the Earth, Knower of the seen and the unseen. You are the arbitrator between Your servants in that which they have disputed. Guide me to the truth by Your leave, in that which they have differed, for verily You guide whom You will to a straight path.’
Attachments
:salam2:
Reading the misleading statements made by some has forced me to post for the first time, although having joined TTI some time back.
The conclusions being made here are based on our very little knowledge on deen, shouldn't we be going to ulema? Please do not mislead others with our own opinions and quoting Quraan and Hadith out of context without a through understanding of this.
It is also saddening to see the rubbish and derogatory comments made about pious predeccessors such as Ml Thaanvi (Rahmaullah). Brother abubaseer you should be careful when you make such claims, these people have passed away and such allegations are serious (remember that Allah Ta'ala is the judge).
Although I am not equipped with knowledge to answer to the abovementioned claims, I am however surrounded by reputable ulema who would put the matter to rest. Inshaalah after I am complete with my exams(on Friday) I would surely try to get an answer to most of the debatable topics here from a reputable mufti and post it.
Reading the misleading statements made by some has forced me to post for the first time, although having joined TTI some time back.
The conclusions being made here are based on our very little knowledge on deen, shouldn't we be going to ulema? Please do not mislead others with our own opinions and quoting Quraan and Hadith out of context without a through understanding of this.
It is also saddening to see the rubbish and derogatory comments made about pious predeccessors such as Ml Thaanvi (Rahmaullah). Brother abubaseer you should be careful when you make such claims, these people have passed away and such allegations are serious (remember that Allah Ta'ala is the judge).
Although I am not equipped with knowledge to answer to the abovementioned claims, I am however surrounded by reputable ulema who would put the matter to rest. Inshaalah after I am complete with my exams(on Friday) I would surely try to get an answer to most of the debatable topics here from a reputable mufti and post it.
saima abdullah
my life iz 4 Allah
asalam o alykim wr wb ..
jasak Allah brother n sisters for ur helpful replies .... may Allah be on ur side ,,, show us right path amen ya rubbi
wsalam alykum wr wb
jasak Allah brother n sisters for ur helpful replies .... may Allah be on ur side ,,, show us right path amen ya rubbi
wsalam alykum wr wb
Hard Rock Moslem
I'm your brother
I hope to see no more comments here, pls I appeal to everyone. Let we go back to our respective learned sheikh to clarify things about the issues here if you are not sure. I'm not siding anyone, pls all calm down.
May Allah make us better understand each other, ameen.
May Allah make us better understand each other, ameen.
:salam2: Dear Brother,
Whatever has been said about The Deobandis are from the books written by Scholars with proofs from their (Deobandi) books.
I would request you and others to please take you time and read the book that is in the previous post, it contains references.
If you are able to prove that it is wrong. I will correct myself. Otherwise truth is more worthy to be followed and Falsehood deserves to be exposed.
After all we all are here to learn!
daywalker
Junior Member
do you learn your deen from internet Users?
Ibn 'Uthaymeen (hafidhahullaah) said:
"I do not say that every scholar is free from committing errors; [for] every human is apt to commit mistakes. If you see a scholar making a mistake, according to your belief, then contact him and try to discuss it with him - If it becomes clear [to you] that the Truth is with him, then it becomes obligatory upon you to follow him. [But] if you find that his statement is wrong, then it is obligatory upon you to refute it, and make his mistake clear. [And] this is because it is not correct to accept a mistake. But do not disparage him, and put him down while he is a scholar, who is well-known to have a good intention. If you are able to say, 'Some people say such and such, and that is a weak opinion.', and then you explain why it is weak - without mentioning the scholar - [then] that is good, and that is best."
Did you discuss with the books of scholars you mentioned with their students about the objections? or do we expect they will come in internet to answer us? or we got the attitude" what i understood , is the correct one, and what i didn´t understood is false!"
yep, but regarding the scholars you are raising objection, aren´t here, neither their students are here to teach us.After all we all are here to learn!