Can i follow 2 (madhabs) schools of thought?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Idris16

Junior Member
:salam2:
How do you know one imam is right and another imam is wrong? dont tell me, you learned from sh.munajjid who said this imam is right and that imam is wrong! if so you aren´t following any imam but only sh.munajjid.

what is the criteria of your judging one is right and another one is wrong? Not everything glance, are Gold. and the word "Seem" is also used as synonym of guess or assuming. so i hope you dont practise the religion by guessing or assuming.
:salam2:
I don't have a single book written by Shaykh Munajjid so dont think i follow him if i follow him it means i follow internet cause his website you can find it on the net.

I hope im not guessing too
 

daywalker

Junior Member
Nope i meant everytime you read a book from a madhab they quote verses and interpret it but are we sure if they interpret it correctly?
thats what i meant
what do i need to know to say this interpratation is right or wrong? guessing or assuming? or seems nice or sounds good? is this the way of saying this interpratation is correct or wrong?
 

Idris16

Junior Member
what do i need to know to say this interpratation is right or wrong? guessing or assuming? or seems nice or sounds good? is this the way of saying this interpratation is correct or wrong?
It's better if you answer that Q!

i read a book about salah and it was great because of all the evidences. now you find madhabs saying make sujud/bow down with hands before the legs but i make sujud with legs before the hands because a sahabi saw the prophet SAW do that..
i hope u understand me
 

daywalker

Junior Member
It's better if you answer that Q!

i read a book about salah and it was great because of all the evidences.
Akhi the evidence you have brought is WEak according to muhaddith ibn hajar(rh) but sahih according to sh.albani its sahih. so what to do now? follow a sahih hadith or a weak hadith? follow ibn hajar or follow sh.albani?
 

Idris16

Junior Member
you mean, you self have knowledge of Usool hadith, Usool fiqh, nasikh -mansookh knowledge? mashallah, its nice to know we have a scholar on our board.
Nope i saw i hope im not guessing whats right and whats wrong:)
dont have knowledge abt those things
 

Idris16

Junior Member
Akhi the evidence you have brought is WEak according to muhaddith ibn hajar(rh) but sahih according to sh.albani its sahih. so what to do now? follow a sahih hadith or a weak hadith? follow ibn hajar or follow sh.albani?
follow a sahih hadith of course..
about those scholars insh'Allah try to read their interpretation..
how do i get to read Ibn Hajar(RA) book/s?
well isnt he a shafi'i?
 

Idris16

Junior Member
Akhi the evidence you have brought is WEak according to muhaddith ibn hajar(rh) but sahih according to sh.albani its sahih. so what to do now? follow a sahih hadith or a weak hadith? follow ibn hajar or follow sh.albani?
its not weak because Tirmidhi and Abu Dawud claimed it to be authentic as the book says so
 

Idris16

Junior Member
how do you know tirmidhi or abu dawud was right or wrong?

you are blindly following the claim of tirmidhi and abu dawud.
:D:D You are only trying to play with my mind...
its not only them but others as well that said its authentic but the book only says ''with others as well'' without saying the names.
So who do you follow DayWalker?
 

daywalker

Junior Member
:D:D You are only trying to play with my mind...
its not only them but others as well that said its authentic
1000 can say something, but you are blind following their claim! as you haven´t study Usool hadith, you are following their claim blindly! how do you know 1000 are right but other 2 are wrong? are you judging a hadith by majority and minority? Truth isn´t depended upon majority or monirity. Islam is the Truth, yet its minority in the world.
but the book only says ''with others as well'' without saying the names.
and this is called blind following, trusting something without knowing the evidence. :astag:
 

Idris16

Junior Member
1000 can say something, but you are blind following their claim! as you haven´t study Usool hadith, you are following their claim blindly! how do you know 1000 are right but other 2 are wrong? are you judging a hadith by majority and minority? Truth isn´t depended upon majority or monirity. Islam is the Truth, yet its minority in the world.

and this is called blind following, trusting something without knowing the evidence. :astag:
i dont understand you is it blind following when i see at others claims?
ok what should i do? only following one madhab?
lol what trusting? who said i trust
abu dawud and tirmidhi are great they wrote it in the books sunan tirmidhi/Abu Dawud
 

Irshaad.K

Junior Member
:salam2:

Brother Idris you should take out some time to read the link I posted earlier in its entirety. The view held by the ahlus sunnah today is that it is imperative for an ordinary layman like me to follow madhab. It is up to the learned scholars to decide on in depth issues. The following of a madhab is not blind following but rather following Quran and Sunnah as understood by great scholars of the yesteryear. Look at it this way, there are different methods outlined in order to perform a medical operation, all of these methods produce the desired results, but one cannot pick and choose according to ones limited knowledge which would definitely botch the operation up!

It is not a problem for learned scholars such as the imams of the haram as well as Sheikh Albanee etc not to follow madhab as they are well versed in the sciences required to make ijtihaad.
 

daywalker

Junior Member
i dont understand you is it blind following when i see at others claims?
you said the book says there are other, but dind´t mention. so you are blind following the claim of the book
lol what trusting? who said i trust
If you dont know usool hadith, how do you know abu dawud and tirmidhi were right?
abu dawud and tirmidhi are great they wrote it in the books sunan tirmidhi/Abu Dawud
and this books contains weak hadith and other things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top