50 Questions And Answers On Islamic Monotheism

[revert2007]

All non muslims,reverts and born muslims may download it and read for better understanding of Islam

Publisher: darussalam
​

 

[revert2007]

I advise everyone not to read this since it has deviant foot notes. This is usually the case with regards to Daru Salaam, which has its base in Saudi arabia

what are u talking about?darussalam is one of the best publisher of islamic books..and all the infromation written in that book is based on quran evidence and sunnah...
i am not working for darussalam by the way..i must tell from where i got the book.

 

[weakslave]

I advise everyone not to read this since it has deviant foot notes. This is usually the case with regards to Daru Salaam, which has its base in Saudi arabia

I would also like to know what you are talking about. And where you have evidence that they are deviant. And what footnotes you are referring to.

As far as I know, they are very reliable and I have never read anything that proves otherwise.

 

[BinKhadija]

Jazak Allah khayar, sister. I'll have a read of it.

I advise everyone not to read this since it has deviant foot notes. This is usually the case with regards to Daru Salaam, which has its base in Saudi arabia

Why do you say so akhi?
They are trustworthy publishers; and I believe here on this Forum they are seen in the same light.

Please let us know why you said so, dear. May be we are wrong.
Wa'salaam

 

[revert2007]

I would also like to know what you are talking about. And where you have evidence that they are deviant. And what footnotes you are referring to.

As far as I know, they are very reliable and I have never read anything that proves otherwise.

exactly brother i dont know what he is talking about.i just came from my quran class and my quran teacher have this book in hard copy and she loves it so much and she asekd me to type it and post so that non muslims can understand better and muslims can use for dawah purpose.so i am sure that it will be on internet and alhamdulilah i found it and i wanna share it on tti....Darussalam is a very famous islamic book publisher.so why is it deviant?i must tell from where i got the book.that is the basic courtesy of copying and pasting something which is not belong to me.

 

[revert2007]

Darussalam is from Saudi arabia and they have been editing books from scholars and taking away parts they dont like because their aim is to spread the Saudi salafi doctrine.

For example the Tafsir Ibn Kathir has been heavily edited, I have spoken with people who know arabic and who has read the arabic book and they have said they have done some heavy editing, so when you read their version, you are not really reading Tafsir Ibn Kathir.

This has been made with other book as well, many brothers have said we should really be carefull with Saudi translations of books, and have warned against this.

This particular article, which the sister posted, has in its footnotes on the word "Kursiy" something which I dont dare even to mention. Far is Allah (swt) above all they are saying.

Also we should be really carefull with what we are reading. We might be impressed by the design of the books or by thinking they are great publisher of islamic books, but not realising in fact they are the callers to Hell-fire concerning which the prophet (pbuh) warned us about and said they would be from us and speak our language. So we must really be carefull about this.

Narrated Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman:



This is from Sahih ul Bukhari

dont worry about it..i know not all perfect..i hv went through the book and they didnt say anything which is not written in quran..

thsi book that i posted is good an du can trust..

u cant make a whole conclusion for all the books..only sauid is a very good muslim country in thsi world by the way...and i dont agree about talking bad about them..they are doing their best to speard islam and we should respect that..if there is some erros..we can avoide it..but cannot make a huge conclusion in such away without any proof.this is very dangerous in islam

 

[weakslave]

Darussalam is from Saudi arabia...

WOWOWOWOW.

Slow down for a second. I don't want to quote every line from your post, but do you realize what you have just done? You have just claimed that all of those who work at DARRUSALAAM and everyone who supports them as "kaafir".

Do you know what the Messenger of Allaah (SAAWS) said?

Narrated Abu Huraira: Allah's Apostle said, "If a man says to his brother, O Kafir (disbeliever)!' Then surely one of them is such (i.e., a Kafir). " - bukhari 73:125

I won't accuse you of anything, but this is how it begins with those who want to spread their opinion, by calling so and so kafir.

Second, you have taken the hadith of the Prophet SAAWS and applied it to a group of people. Have you looked at what the scholars said about this hadith, and who it refers to? Show me where you got your interpretation of this hadith.

Third,

I have no idea what "footnotes" you are talking about. I read the document, I didn't find any "footnotes" that mention "kursiy".

Fourth,

Since when did "salafi" become a deviant sect!???!!! SubhanaAllaah how shaytaan misguides.

Fifth,

The full Tafsir of ibn Kathir is not actually for everyone to read. First point: he was a human being. Second point: He collected all of his evidence using a combination of Quraan, Sunnaah, and "israeliate" meaning things from the books of the people of Israel (torah, bible).

If DARRUSALAM was to translate tafsir ibn kathir and ONLY include things from the Quraan and Sunnaah, I do not see why it should matter to you. If you are a scholar and wished to study all of the evidence and the sources then you can find the original in arabic and read it yourself. I do not even see a benefit in mentioning things which cannot be verified as authentic (ie. things not from the Quran and the authentic sunnaah).

The biggest harm that arises from that is people start quoting the interpretation from ibn Kathir without actually realizing the source.

Sixth,

Brother I am right here. And I am waiting for the evidence that you have against DARRUSALAAM.

I hope that you are not taking the words of people and using that as your opinion on the matter. It's easy for everyone to be a blind follower, but this is not what Islam teaches. Islam teaches us to question the authenticity of every word said regarding this religion, and I question your opinion and your judgment, just like how you should question the opinions of those you have gotten your information from. A baseless opinion has no place in this religion, and it leads to misguidance.

And Allaah knows best.

 

[weakslave]

My discussion with you ends here. You did not give evidence for anything you said, and you said things in your previous post that you now denied. You have been listening to friends and you are convinced of what they have told you. I cannot change that, only Allaah can. Ask Allaah to guide you to the truth, and not to what you have heard. May Allaah guide you to the truth. May Allaah guide us all to the truth!

My last comment will be: people should be subject to the interpretation of the Quraan using explanations from the Quraan and the Sunnah. This is the most complete form of Tafsir that we need. Anything additional is for the scholars and academic purposes only. Tafsir ibn Kathir is not perfect, it is not a holy book, it is not all 100% from the Quraan and the Sunnah. It is a great collection of books however, compiled by a great scholar in a great manner.

---

 

[ahmed_indian]

And they have books where they claim certain things such as that dismantling the Shariah and replacing it with man-made laws is lesser kuffr. And other issues too, such as likening Allah (swt) to his creation, claiming they are the saved sect and so on.

brother, though i agree with u in certain points like they divided Tauheed in 3 catgories. it was not done by earlier famous Imams (ra).

but can u pls show the proofs about:

1. they said that man-made laws are lesser kufr

2. likening Allah to His creation.

PS: pls quote the statements of real scholars. not someone unknown.