daywalker
Junior Member
we dont need to assume. Proof that they didn´t know it by statement of their students.If you put doubtness by saying they were busy, then you gotta put doubt all of their work or? And if not, then proof this specific topic. How many people were busy?Imam Nawawi rahimahullahu, and all of those imams were busy people, sometime they put an atsar without checking the authencity of the atsar.
Ibn taymiyah(rh) busy?
Imam ahmad(rh) were busy?
Ibn qayyum (rh) were busy?
ibn abidin(rh) were busy?
hafiz hukami(rh) were busy?
They are all sooo busy that they couldn´t check the authority, and certainly scholar of 20th century like sh.albani(rh) got enough time to do a job(checking the authority) for which job other scholars hadn´t any time?
Dont assume sheikh, dont use words like : might,could,would. FAtwa is present.Eventhough we accept the use of ayat Al Qur'an as Tamimah or protection, we won't accept it to be use as Tiwalah, where the atsar that it could be use as Tiwalah?
Sheikh you know better what things are hujjah.And ibntaymiyah(rh),imam nabawi(rh),imam ahmad(rh) .... they also know what is hujjah for islam, and after all these things, they give permissblity for using.We're talking about people who said that specific Surah and ayat as to have effects to specific illness, now where is the dalil that Rasulullah been saying all these things?