:salam2: What makes Gaddafi an apostate ? How is Gaddafi different from Ben Ali, Mubarrak and Saleh? Or are they the same ? If they are different, does that mean the revolutionaries in Tunisia, Egypt, etc did wrong rebelling against them ? And yes, clearly the rebellion is not to establish Islamic Shariah. You can not establish shariah by alliance the one who rejects Islam. and ^^ agreed with sister Aapa.