If you doubt about the Quranic Verses and Sunnah than Allah (swt) will increase your doubt and you'll end up being a "MUQALLID"....
Allah tells you that such people end up as Kafirs, not Muqallids. You go against the Quran yet again.
وأما الذين في قلوبهم مرض فزادتهم رجسا إلى رجسهم وماتوا وهم كافرون (Al-Tawbah)
Check the Tafseer. Oh wait:
Well bro Aziboy, I am Layman of TTI... cuz i can't speak Arabic... :lol:
Tough luck.
Since the Shariah is in Arabic (not Punjabi), you can still not verify what any scholar is telling you, because the translation of the Shariah is not Shariah. You will forever be a blind follower. Very sorry to break to you the harsh reality. You are, essentially, a stumped Muqallid.
it feels very sad when our own brothers have different opinions about Islam as Our Prophet (saww) has not left a single place for doubt, this is our responsibility if they have an opinion clashes Sunna we have to rectify it... but still people will follow their desires and instead of going and asking a scholar they prefer Sheikh Google as their Mufti....
Well that's you and Aziboy, Imams of copy-pastes that got you nowhere. Islam has a dynamic legal system which is not stagnant, thanks to the efforts of the scholars. Ever since the Prophet (peace be upon him) passed away, the process of Ijtihad in new cases started.
I presented to Aziboy the case study of the
Musharrikah sceanrio of inhertiance - there is no clear verse or Hadith therein. How do you solve that riddle? Enlighten us in light of Kitab and Sunnah. Spare us your insults for a change.
not denying that we cannot derive ruling fom Qur'an and Hadith, if i go and ask any scholar about an Hadith and he give me a ruling according to Qur'an and Sunnah than i am not doing Taqleed im doing investigation...
OK he is obliged to give you evidence. But evidence is in Arabic. He is not obliged to give you a translation. Also, he is not obliged to give you anything at all if he feels you would become confused. Since you are a confused individual, I would advise any person to deprive you of evidence, since you don't deserve it. You should focus on cleaning your heart first and stop thinking ill of other Muslims.
Sister in Islam, i am reading your post word by word but i dont find any logic for Taqleed in it... there is no denying about being a Layman, whilst our focus is on Taqleed...
So a layman must investigate? Is that what you are saying? Does your whole family know from Kitab and Sunnah how to do Istinja? Or do they just clean themselves? Let's start from there, shall we?
on one hand you telling me that a Layman is a Blind Follower and on the other you telling me that Layman has a ability to understand Aqeeda related stuff...
No, the main point is that a layman identifies a trustworthy scholar, who would point out to the layman that there are matters in Deen that are Aqeedah (fundamentals). Laymen are only obliged to identify a scholar who would tell them this. And by the way, following a scholar in matters of fundamentals is not called Taqleed, because the domain of Taqleed is in non-fundamentals only.
If i were to accept your opinions than why don't i become a Shia'a? their claims can be found in Qur'an as well... they claim the word Shia'a is mentioned around 4-5 times... no word such as "Sunni" is there than how will justify my religion??? i am blind follower i'll be forced to accept that cuz their evidence is in Qur'an.... what are your opnions on this?
I thought about giving you a proper answer, but then I thought against it, because it is beyond your comprehension. So what I will now tell you is that you shouldn't become a Shi`ah, but you should become a Mu`tazilite as you have proven yourself to be all along. The term is in the Quran:
وَأَعْتَزِلُكُمْ وَمَا تَدْعُونَ مِن دُونِ اللَّهِ (Maryam)
So don't worry about taking the path of the Baghdadi Mu`tazilites. Just make sure you let everyone know that you are reviving their creed from scratch.
Answer by The Permanent Committee: What is meant by the term 'Ummah' in this Hadith is the Ummah of response which shall be divided into seventy-three sects; seventy-two of which are deviant who practice innovated religious practices that do not constitute apostasy. Each shall be tortured in accordance to its innovations, and deviation, except for those whom Allaah pardons and forgives. Their final abode will be Paradise. The only sect that will be safe is Ahlus-Sunnah wal Jama'ah, who adhere to the Sunnah of the Prophet (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam), and hold fast to what he and his companions (may Allaah be pleased with them) were holding. It is they about whom the Prophet (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam) said: "A group of my Ummah shall remain steadfast, on the truth, victorious, unharmed by those who oppose them, and do not support them, until the death or until the Day of Resurrection."
As for those whose innovation casts them out of Islam, they belong to the Ummah of invitation (mankind at large) not the Ummah of response. They shall remain in the Hell-Fire forever, and this is the most valid opinion.
It is also said that the term 'Ummah' in this Hadith means the Ummah of invitation, which is a general term including all those to whom the Prophet (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam) was sent (i.e., mankind) those who believe and those who do not believe. Whereas the term 'the saved sect' is the Ummah of response, which strictly applies to those who believe in the Prophet (salallaahu 'alaihi wa sallam), trustfully, and die on this condition. This is the sect that will be safe from [the] Fire; either by prior punishment or without prior punishment, and their final abode will Paradise.[/COLOR][/I]
Al-Bukhari nos. 71, 3641 and Muslim no. 1920.
The Permanent Committee
Source: Fatawa Islamiyah, Vol. 1
Are you joking? Another copy-paste? From the Saudi Lajnah!?
Do you even know what they say on Taqleed? I think you know by now that they too oppose you.
Understand this well: you are a nobody, and nobody supports you.
I await your final response to the above. I personally don't think you should be banned though.